We like Stevia in many things, but the overall flavor profile didn't do it for us. I appreciate that it doesn't have Sucralose, but this mix would be better served with real sugar. Additional calories aside, I would at least be able to want more than my first (and final) shake. The only plus was my wife was able to easily open our sample bottle. We will be donating the remaining 11.

This product used to be great when it was in the plastic bottles. It has since changed to not only cardboard boxes, but also to a watered down version of its previous self. I immediately regretted my decision of buying them from the first taste after the switch. I still gave it two stars because, well it has more protein than well water.

I had never tried this brand before, and I got this because it seemed to be the cleanest protein shake available. This is the most disgusting chocolate protein shake I’ve ever tasted! You’re better off getting the shakes with all the additives like Premier Protein or Fairlife. I literally had to plug my nose and chug it as fast as I could! I would have just thrown it, but I was desperate to meet my morning protein goal! I then took the rest of the case and returned it.

The first box of this shake I purchased was fine. It was not the best tasting one I've had but it was good enough. I liked that it had far less ingredients that some others. The second time I purchased it is a different story. It taste so bad. It really taste like sour milk or old cheese. I will be returning this asap. It is just gross.

Bring back the Protein Isolate (brown bottles!). The new formula uses whey protein like all the other terrible options. This one WAS unique, it WAS better, and now it's just bottom tier vs Fairlife. So I've switch to Fairlife until the old formula returns.

It's just ok, you definitely taste the sweetener. Unlike Fairlife which has a good taste. Tried this on a sale, won't buy again.

As others have stated, these taste terrible. Absolutely the worst tasting protein drink I have ever had. This explains the sale price, do not buy these you will regret it.

Yikes. Awful taste. Dumped after a single sip. Will absolutely try to get my money back. Usual brand is OWYN or Members Mark protein. This was on sale. It really tastes like dish soap.

I love these %26 I'm sad they aren't available anymore. Sometimes I hate shopping at Sam's because of this. You find something that works, with clean ingredients %26 its gone. I guess i should've stocked up.

These are the worst tasting protein shakes u have ever had. They taste loke rotten milk I want my money back.