My dog is getting pretty old and has bad teeth, so I've been looking for a softer treat for her. She absolutely loves these! They are gentle on her stomach as well, which is important because she usually has trouble digesting new treats. Honestly, they smell great. I was surprised when I first opened it, smells like people food. Thank you Sam's Club!

Our German Shepherd/Rottie mix LOVES these waffles. He begs by the cabinet for them. He has learned to come inside when called at 5 years old because he loves these treats so much. He will do anything for them lol! They stay soft even if you leave the bag open and don't get stale like a lot of other kinds of treats. They are not crunchy. They almost have the consistency of a fig newton.

My 2 small dogs, Lady 12yrs %26 Lexi 11yrs old absolutely love these treats. They both stand next to counter or lead me to the counter where the treats are and whine. It's so funny. I've never seen them react this way over dog treats. So I'm purchasing another bag just in case they sell out. I do hope that Sam's will consider selling these year around. Lady %26 Lexi will be so forever grateful. Thanks ♥️ 🐶

I cannot tell you how good these doggy because I didn't personally eat any! What I can tell you-- when you open the bag it smells good .. maybe like gingerbread cookies? My dog is fairly picky and if she didn't like the treat, she would just walk away. They are about the size of a triscuit, so I normally give her 2-3 treats.

My dogs absolutely LOVE the Winter Waffle dog treats... so much. If I give them a couple different kinds, they will always eat the waffles first. I sent my granddogs some for Christmas and these treats spoiled them and only want the waffles. Both daughters are Sam's customers and will order more!

My dogs are picky when it comes to treats. They absolutely love these. They smell amazing, have natural ingredients and stay surprisingly soft after open. I have already stocked piled these so they have them after the holidays. Please continue to make these every year!

I have two standard poodles and a Jindo and they love these snacks. Mind you, they love all snacks but they REALLY love these. One day one of my dogs broke into a bag and ate all of them. *face palm* - they even smell good. I hope they keep them around past “Winter”.

Amazing dog treats that even the pickest dog love! My dog shuns all treats except real chicken. She is spoiled and I have given away so many dog treats to my Granddogs. I tried this one out for the review thinking this was also going to the Granddogs and you would have thought this was cooked chicken cause she begged for more. She even learned "shake" as a command with these treats. I HIGHLY recommend these if your Dog is picky.

My dog loves these! I love that they are reasonably priced!

I Dogs go crazy for these. Plus the smell is delicious not that dog treat smell