I'm very careful what I feed my doodle and the ingredients are just fine for dogs not to mention my doodle loves them. Even when given options with other treats he'll settle in this one 99% of the time. I'll break them into quarters when working with training.

I cannot tell you how good these doggy because I didn't personally eat any! What I can tell you-- when you open the bag it smells good .. maybe like gingerbread cookies? My dog is fairly picky and if she didn't like the treat, she would just walk away. They are about the size of a triscuit, so I normally give her 2-3 treats.

My little doggy loves these gingerbread waffle treats. She's a very small dog so we can easily break these up for her to enjoy. The best part is that they are SOFT! They break very nicely for little mouths. The treats also smell pretty good- very strong gingerbread smell. My dog will definitely enjoy these all fall.

They smell amazing—just like gingerbread—and the texture is perfect, not too hard or too soft. I love that they're made with real chicken and natural ingredients like cranberries and cinnamon. They make the perfect festive snack, and even my picky eater gets excited when I grab the bag. I definitely recommend these treats for the holiday season!

My dog gobbled up these treats! They actually have a pretty pleasant smell (which is rare). And I love how soft they are - we are trying to train my dog on different things, so I like that I can break them into smaller pieces. And it is a nice big bag! There are a ton of treats in there! My dog seems to love the flavor!

Never really thought I would review dog treats. But the way my dogs devoured these treats and begged for them. I've never seen was any other treat the I've ever bought for them. They are good quality and a great size for a dog treat not too big

Smells delicious. I was so close to eating it. My dogs loved it. They go crazy for these sweet treats. They finished the whole big bag in 1 week. I had to go back and buy 5 more bags. It's so good. I can't rave enough.

These dog treats are quite large and would be great for large dogs but I have small dogs and have to cut them in two. Dogs seem to like them okay-not really impressed with these dog treat as they are sticky and kinda messy.

These treats are perfect size for my large pitty and they smell delicious! He really likes them a lot. As soon as he hears me open the bag he comes running. It came in a three pound bag as well so it's a great value for the money!

I don’t know which of all the good ingredients it is but my dogs love this stuff!! I have been training one of them and this is making it so much easier. I recommend this to any pet lover out there. It works