Try it and give it time. I don’t understand the bad reviews of cats not eating it. I have 9 indoor and 6 outdoor cats. That’s a lot of cats to please. I have some picky eaters too, but they have had no complaints. They love this food. I’ve been looking for a healthier option to prevent diarrhea. One of my cats has a sensitive stomach. After doing research I’ve been looking for something with no artificial colors/flavors, corn/wheat free, but also affordable with big quantity with so many cats. This has been the best change for my cats. No more diarrhea. I wish they sold it in my local club as well. I’m always having to order ahead of time to have it shipped.

We switched from Purina to this for our cats, and we have been so happy with it! The ingredients are cleaner, and there are no dyes, etc. We have also noticed that our cats are not nearly as gassy as they were on the Purina food. The price point is amazing as well! I decided to give this food a try despite some of the negative reviews, and I am so very glad that I did!

PHOS LEVELS _______________________________________________ Hello XXXX! Warmest Greetings from Sam's Club! This is XXXXX from Sam's Club Member's Mark Team. We hope that this email finds you well. Thank you for your inquiry regarding the Member’s Mark™ Prime Feast with Chicken and Salmon Cat Food for All Life Stages. Please find the phosphorus levels below: Dry Matter Basis: 1.7% As Fed Basis: 1.6% If you have any further questions or need additional nutritional information, feel free to reach out. Thank you for being a valued Sam’s Club member. Warm regards, XXXX, Member's Mark Customer Service Reference %23: XXXX

My cats like it, but I can tell its not good for their tummies. Their poops are horrid again, like when they were on the cheap cat food. I only bought this because they were out of Blue Buffalo, but now I see its a replacement as BB is not listed at all. I will not buy this again.

My cats really didn't seem to care for it at first. But they were still eating it. Typically I fill their dish daily. But this lingers on for almost 2 days. We went back to our old go to after I noticed one cat wasn't eating at all and losing weight. Instantly ran to the dish went I filled it with our old go to brand.

For the price point seems to be pretty good quality. Hope this isn't a product that will be short lived and go away.

My cats loved the taste and flavor, but after a few weeks of eating, they both started throwing it up. I had to switch back to another brand.

My cats hate it! Took it to work for the stray cats, same thing.

Perfect size pieces for kittens! Mom and babies love this! Good ingredients. We just sit this out for grazing. This will always be a repurchase for us!

We have three cats, one that is 13, 11 and 5. Unfortunately none of them seem to like this and the 13 year old has been throwing up from it almost daily since we got it.