Had to buy this since Sam's stopped carrying the Blue Buffalo Tastefuls which all 5 of my cats LOVED! They won't even touch this stuff. I pour it in their bowl and they glare at me in disgust. Very disappointing.

The bag is great the way it closes back up easily but I feed wild cats and they are starving but they still don’t eat it. I throw so much away. Needs to taste better for cats to eat it. Wish I had my money back. Won’t ever buy again.

I was really hoping my cats would like this but that was a huge NO . I even gave to feral cats outside and they turned their nose up at this food . It's pretty bad when the deer and raccoons won't eat it either. Don't buy, waste of money.

The ingredients sound great but my cats (and I have many) don't like it. I also feed cat food to my wild ducks. They like Purina cat chow but they don't like the Members Mark chow. Wish Sam's would make it a better product.

This cat food has been a great buy. I like that it’s made with real chicken and salmon, and my cats actually enjoy eating it. It’s also been easy on their stomachs, with no digestion issues, which is a big plus. Their coats look softer and shinier too, so it seems to be doing a good job supporting overall health. For a 25-lb bag, it’s a solid value and I’ll definitely keep buying it.

Our cats love this food but we are on our last bag. We can’t find it in any warehouse anymore. They’ve been eliminated from stock. And the app will not let us purchase any for shipping. It says it’s available for shipping but when we go to check out, it says unavailable. Our cats don’t want any other food so this is very disappointing that other people are able to purchase this food but we cannot in southern California

It caused two out of three cats to have an allergic reaction. A cat allergic to a new food could potentially experience nasal congestion, among other symptoms. Food allergies in cats can manifest in various ways, including respiratory issues like sneezing and nasal discharge, as well as skin and gastrointestinal problems. 

i was excited for my cat to try this. Looked good with ingredients, price, etc. Only problem is she wouldn't touch it! i tried giving some to neighbors in my apartment building who have cats. only one cat out of 6 would eat it. I ended up returning it. i can't believe those incentivized reviews. Two dogs ran into a neighbor's apartment who had cats. The dogs gobbled up the cat's food but wouldn't touch the Member's Mark cat food that I had given her to try!

We have a 10 cat colony in our house and they all love this food. Their coats are shiny and soft, they have energy, and seem to be happy and healthy, including their bowels (which is important). IF I had a complaint, it would be that it is not always in stock...and when it is not available, one cat in particular will not eat. We have tried other foods that are similar and she won't touch them (onlu canned food and we don't want to get her used to those as they are treats). Hope they get it back in soon! Our cats would be much happier!

I opted to switch to this dry food because the recipe is more nutritious than similarly priced alternatives. It's always a risk changing food, but I am glad I took a risk on this one. So far theres been no issues with transition. For context my family owns 5 cats and each one ate the food. Firstly, the flavour. This is the first dry cat food where our cats actively tried to open the food container to eat more. Needles to say, I believe they like the taste. Size and texture, think BB pellet size as opposed to kibble size. Again, our cats had no issues with the change in shape. I did have to adjust the amount I feed since the overall volume per cup is different (I weigh the food beforehand). Thirdly, the smell of the cat food I did not find obnoxious in any way, maybe your typical dry cat food smell. Although it does not linger in the air. I decant the food into a container. However, I can see how a resealable bag would be useful to some owners. it's a nice touch that could otherwise be useful. Overall, I would recommend this, and as long as Sams Club continues to sell it. It will be the cat food of choice for my cats.