Got this food to try for my outdoor cat and he absolutely loves it. It was delivered on time and fresh to my door. The kibble seems like great quality and for the price you just can’t beat it! So glad Sam’s club has so many great options for my pets!

My cats hate it

Member's Mark Prime Feast with Chicken and Salmon Dry Cat Food appears to be comparable with other leading dry cat food brand ingredients. My eight year old cat who has always eaten a different name brand seemed to like it. He sniffed around at it initially and then cleaned the plate. I will alternate with his regular dry food for cost effectiveness. All in all a good deal.

At first I didn’t think my cat liked it very much because when I opened the bag she smelled it & walked away. I went ahead & put a bowl out & she did end up eating it. It was next to her regular food so she had a choice. The kibble is small which is nice for older cats. She hasn’t had any tummy problems or throwing up which is always a concern starting a new food.

So far my cats are loving this food. I have 4 cats and one of them is a picky eater, I even have her food separated from the others because she won’t eat anything if other cats are too close. All 4 cats are eating well, no complaints so far! This food is nutritious and tasty from what they are telling us. Will continue to buy this, great size and value.

To be fair, I do have picky cats whom do not like change. I was excited for them to try a different food. They disliked it immediately. I mixed it with their normal food and they ate around the Prime Feast food. I finally gave in and mixed it with some canned food and they begrudgingly at it. It took them two days to finish the bowl. I went back to mixing with their normal food and slowly tapered off how much normal food I put in. Eventually they gave in and are eating it. No issues to their stomach or any difference in bathrooms behaviors.

None of my cats like it

I recently received a bag of the Members Mark Prime Feast with chicken and salmon for cats to try as part of a promotion plan. The bag I received was 25lbs so it will last quite a while for my one cat who, so far, seems to have no problem with it. My cat is pretty picky about her food so it’s a good sign that she likes it.

I have three cats of different stages. A newbie that we rescued, a 3 month kitten and a 10 year old cat. This is the perfect kibble for them. They love it and I love all the essential nutrients it provides for all ages. Try it and you won’t be disappointed.

My cats will basically eat any cat food but this new food has good ingredients and a nice quality it seems. The dog tries his best to sneak in and eat this as well. But he also likes litter box nuggets. So...buy for the quality of ingredients since my animals don't have a refined taste palette.