My dog loves these!!! They are convenient for training, walks or a simple treat; and are odorless! They are no longer carried at my local Sam's Club. I went to order 4 bags online and apparently they are not available for shipping! This is very disappointing!!!

My cat loves these. He has “tender cuts” food with freeze dried bits but they are nothing alike. I squish them so he doesn't just try to inhale the large treat. He can get up to 12 a day but that seems a lot at this point. He loves them after dry, I sometimes dunk or soak them in some warm water. I hope they continue to be available and he continues to enjoy them without any issues!

I seriously hope these treats come back—because nothing else even comes close. I have three dogs (two Shih Tzus and a German Shepherd), and this is the ONLY treat they all consistently love. When I open this bag of treats, they start doing circus tricks (jumping, spinning, sneezing, the works). And it's not just my crew—my neighbor's Pomeranian and cat literally show up looking for these, and my sister's two beagles and her cat go absolutely crazy for them. Her cat won't even bother with other treats, but will beg for these. They're super versatile too. I can give them as-is or crumble them over food, which makes mealtime a lot easier when someone is being picky. And for the price? You really can't beat it. I've spent more on “premium” treats that ended up completely ignored. If you're looking for a treat that every pet actually gets excited about, this is it. Please bring them back!

Ewww! Smells gross. Dogs forced it down because ... treats. They were very hesitant and approached it as if it was broccoli. The very best part is that they both got the cha-chas afterwards. One outside - one inside. I think they each had 2 little pieces. Hard pass. These are going back to the Club.

I use these as high reward treats for my two dogs. They love them. My cat even loves them too. I wish they would carry them again at my Sam’s. I can only order them online.

Please, Please, Please, bring more of this back, even if you only have it as a shipping order. My dogs and cats love this item. Why drop it, or make something new when this is a hit to begin with?

Wow, my four dogs and 3 cats all LOVE these treats! Two of my pets have lost all their teeth due to illness, and thankfully they can enjoy these treats just like all the others. I love the simple ingredient list, that the food is sourced in America, and that both my dogs and my cats can enjoy them. It would be even better if they were also made in America. Packaging is great and easy to read. I'm always pleased with the Member's Mark brand items, and will definitely continue to buy these treats! I'm a loyal and frequent Sam's Club shopper.

my dachshund mix loves these treats. they are single ingredient, small enough for her mouth and the amount in the big is generous at the price point. very affordable and last a while for a small dog because of how much you get in the bag. they come in a resealable bag which is a plus. now they are out of stock. 😟please bring these back!

my cats and dogs love these i have a picky dog who hates waking up for breakfast but i shake the bag by her bowl and she comes runnin and eats everything also use for training and there so soft and perfect size for smaller dogs and the amount for the price is incredible dog treats r so expensive thank you members mark for giving a good priced option

I had to give these a try after I discovered them at my local sams club store today. My two cats love these! Affordable and you get a good size bag for the price. This is now going to be my go to freeze dry treats for my two cats. Please keep selling these sams club.