I haven't made the roll out, cookie cutter version but drop cookies turned out great. Four star rating only because individual packages were clear. I was hoping for traditional packaging so I could include them with gifts.

The "butter-recipe" version is easier for me to make since I don't usually have any margarine or, more specifically, an abundance of 60% vegetable oil margarine.

Add your own flavor elements, or not. Up to you. Great batter mix for sugar cookies. Saves a ton of time and well packaged by dividing the total mix into 5 sealed bags. Well done, Sam's Club. Divine!

I followed the recipe for cut out cookies, I couldn't get the dough to roll out for anything. It was clumpy and hard to handle. Ended up throwing it away!

I loved these cookies! The price went up since the last time that I purchased them. I made a batch and they smelled and tasted so good. The bad news is that I ate everyone one of them in one day!

This is a game changer! It’s very good and a super value! I often make cookies from scratch, but not sugar cookies. Since I have found these, this will be my go to!

I've been buying this cookie mix for years. It tastes great plus it's a really good price. I buy a couple of extra boxes to use throughout the year because you can only buy these cookie at Christmas time.

When you are used to cooking from scratch for decades, trusting a box mix is questionable. However, these were wonderful. The flavor was good, the dough easy to work with. Will definitely use these again.

The five pouches inside the box are packaged in clear and non-decorated bags. They do not have the regular design nor do they list the baking instructions.

What is there to say other than its a cheaper pack of 5 than buying on sale even at the typical grocery store. This is the value Sams can and should provide on all their products which is NOT the case always.