These were an impulse buy. They would be great for Halloween. They really taste like a pb&J sandwich.

These are not good at all. The jelly tastes funny. I wish we wouldn’t have bought this big of a bag.

Loved these. Strawberry was my favorite of the two. But as good as they are doesn’t beat the original or the Carmel. 😀

I really like the PB&J idea. I think adding dehydrated strawberry paste or freeze dried strawberry would have been better than jam/jelly. It was too gooped & sugary for me.

I tried both but the strawberry is my favorite! Keep the strawberry one PLEASE

Very tasty , the peanut butter combination is perfect ,it's very soft and and crunchy ,portion is perfect ,worth every penny you can definitely try it on your own

Yummmmyyyy love this snack! Tastes so fresh all the time. It's not to sugary. and its also perfect and bite sized. The peanut flavor isn't too much it's has good amount of ingredients

If you're looking for more Reese butter goodness there's also the Reese creamy peanut butter which gets props for being smooth and delicious on sandwiches or with fruit

This did not taste right at all. It tasted like expired jelly with some peanut butter and chocolate. On the outside it looked like a regular Reese's but gross

I think this is delicious! The strawberry is not at all overpowering and it provides a delightful fruity finish that is not present in the original cups. The amount of peanut butter is excellent— exactly how I like it!