I think this is delicious! The strawberry is not at all overpowering and it provides a delightful fruity finish that is not present in the original cups. The amount of peanut butter is excellent— exactly how I like it!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] If you are a fan of Reese’s and love peanut butter and jelly in general, you have to try the new Reese’s big cups with strawberry jelly! Pb&j is such a comfort food and Reese’s cups are a classic! You have to try these. You get the classic Reese’s cup which is already delicious and add jelly. I love these things! So good!

I came across these Reese's PB&J big cups at my local supermarket. They were new so I wanted to give them a try. These were so big that you can easily share them with someone. Which is what I did, we all sampled a few bites. The layer of strawberry flavored filling with the peanut butter really does remind you of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Just minus the bread and covered with chocolate instead. Reese's cups are my favorite candy bar but these are a little too sweet for my taste. This is not one that I would eat very often. There delicious but the strawberry filling makes them too rich in sweetness.

I first bought these from BJ’s . Tried ordering them from Walmart. They didn’t seem fresh. The chocolate didn’t have the same taste as the first time I had it.

These weren’t too bad. I had my reservations but since I love the candy and PB&J sandwiches, I thought why not?! I preferred the grape ones the most because you can really taste the flavor. My fiancé loved the strawberry flavor more. It’s worth a try.

These caught my eye and the picture on the package looked enticing, so I grabbed a bag. But I was very disappointed. These Reese's PB&J cups have a very artificial and off taste, which was surprising as I could barely see any of the so called jam / jelly inside them. I find the grape had more of an off taste than the strawberry Really not impressed, some things are best left as a classic.

I'm a huge Reese's fan, but Reese's PB&J flavor was a total miss for me. The strawberry filling tastes very artificial and very overly sweet. It just doesn't pair well. Instead of that classic Reese's balance, the flavors clash and leave a weird after taste, and the texture is also off. I really wanted to like it.

Holding it over the trash because that's what it is. I don't know how they have made this pass a taste test. Awful. Ruined a perfectly good peanut butter cup.

These were already outdated and the taste was not good and they were dry and crumbly. I ended up throwing the bag away.

I hate to say it but these are gross