Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Select & Tear 2-Ply Paper Towel 15 rolls, 150 sheets/roll for
Member's Mark Select & Tear 2-Ply Paper Towel 15 rolls, 150 sheets/roll

Member photos

  • +161 images
Sort by |
Showing 4,121-4,130 of 27,974 reviews
Mar 14, 2022
Aburu
1 out of 5 stars review

Huge quality drop

I’ve been buying Sam’s paper towel brand for years and until recently it was comparable to Charming brand quality. Something happened within the last few months. Different supplier or different formulation. The result is a poor quality product. The paper is much thinner and it breaks apart easier. A year ago I would have given it 5 starts. Today it gets one.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
reply from Consumer Relations

Thank you for your feedback and our apologies for these issues. We will certainly forward this to our team. Please call us at 888-301-0332 so that we may obtain important product information and possible samples for review.

Mar 13, 2024
NK
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Way too thin to be of any medium to heavy use!

Don’t bother!

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
Feb 28, 2025
Jen
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring back FULL SHEETS!

For those that don't mind being forced to buy select-a-size they are fine. If you need full sheet, Sam's quit stocking them in their brand or any other. I keep my membership primarily for papergoods and produce. Sam's is forcing me to take my business elsewhere since they are no longer stocking what I need. This "membership" just isnt worth it anymore. Disapointed.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
reply from Consumer Relations

Hi there. Our apologies for this occurrence. Please reach out to Sam’s Club Customer Service at 1 (888) 746-7726 to better assist.

Aug 2, 2025
PR shopper
1 out of 5 stars review

bad change

Sorry to see the recent change in quality. Probably half the thickness and absorbency compared to last purchase. It now takes two hands to pull a sheet from a roll without it tearing (not along perforated marks). I took a little step down in quality from Bounty a while ago but got used to it. There's no way I'll accept this new downgrade, just another item I won't buy.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
reply from Consumer Relations

Good Afternoon. We share your disappointment and we would like to try to assist as this is certainly not something we like to hear. If you have a moment to call us, please keep the product handy so we can obtain important manufacturing date code information. You may reach us at 888-301-0332. We look forward to hearing from you!

Feb 27, 2018
Laurie
1 out of 5 stars review

AWFUL! CHEAP! NOT ABSORBENT! TEAR CROOKED!

I have been loyal to this paper towel for many many years. UNTIL this new packaging obviously meant changes on the product as well! This change apparently happened to save the company money - these towels are made cheaper, feel cheaper, tear apart from the roll all kinds of crazy, not as absorbent. Might as well buy the super cheapo paper towels from the grocery store - feels, looks and acts like that cheapo quality!

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
Jun 24, 2022
NT
3 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Meh

Not horrible, but wouldn’t buy these again. It’s hard to just have one sheet tear off, usually end up with two. Which then ends up being fine because it takes two of these to clean things up opposed to usually needing only one sheet of Bounty paper towels. Doesn’t feel like it’s worth the cost savings to buy.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
reply from Consumer Relations

Good Afternoon. We are sorry to hear about your disappointment. Please call us at 888-301-0332, so that we may talk to you in more detail regarding your feedback and obtain helpful manufacturing information to review your concerns. Hope to hear from you.

Jan 10, 2018
ToniT
1 out of 5 stars review

New & Improved? AWFUL!!

I have no idea what happened to these towels, but they aren't worth 10 cents! Two ply? Ok, they are...if you think a super thin tissue of sandpaper counts as a ply. They are flimsy, thin, scratchy....not near as soft and durable as they were. My husband thinks they feel oily or something. I always recommended the Member's Mark brand because they were equal if not better than the name brand. Well, guess I am going to the brand name. I have a huge batch of these to use up first. Guess I could return them...maybe I will.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
Feb 27, 2023
Lisa
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible product new cheap design same package

These used to be the best paper towels. I bought a package thinking they were the same paper towels we have been buying since it wasn’t marked new design. This new design is crap sheets are cheap and separate from each other. Will not be wasting my money again.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
reply from Consumer Relations

Good Morning Lisa. We are sorry to hear about your disappointment. Please call us at 888-301-0332, so that we may talk to you in more detail regarding your feedback and obtain helpful manufacturing information to review your concerns. Hope to hear from you.

Jul 23, 2022
Steve B
1 out of 5 stars review

Disappointed in Quality

I've been purchasing the same brand paper towels for years from Sam's and have never had an issue until now. The last batch of paper towels I purchased recently felt as thin as toilet paper and the price increased so I would expect the quality would not change because of that alone. If the price stayed the same and the quality degraded that would be one thing but to go up several dollars on the price quality should not. Very dissatisfied for the 1st time with sams and now feel I'm going to have to pay close attention to see if quality has changed on other items now.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
reply from Consumer Relations

Good Afternoon Steve! We are so sorry for this experience since what you're describing definitely doesn't match the quality standards we stand by for our Member’s Mark Paper Towels. If you still have any remaining product left, please hold onto it so we can obtain important lot code information inside the cardboard roll and retrieve samples for review. If you have time, please call us at 888-301-0332 and we will be happy to address these issues. We look forward to hearing from you.

Jan 27, 2026
Amanda
1 out of 5 stars review

ughhh. I'm so irritated with the way my last pack of these won't fit on my Kitchen Aid paper towel holder, been getting these exact paper towels for years without any issues and with the last pack, every roll I've tried will not go on the holder. Super bummed esp considering I just had rotator cuff surgery and down to one arm. I usually end up tearing up half the roll trying to force it on. For $20 this is unacceptable, now I'm gonna be worried for my next purchases.

Helpful?37YEP9R6BHPD15390012477
reply from Consumer Relations

Good Morning Amanda, We share your disappointment and we would like to try to assist as this is certainly not something we like to hear. If you have a moment to call us, please keep the product handy so we can obtain important manufacturing date code information. You may reach us at 888-301-0332. We look forward to hearing from you!