This is a good product. I got just what I expected. I have gotten this butter several times, and it has always been good. The price has recently gone up, which is why I only gave it a 4 rating on value.

I have been buying Sam's butter for a long time. The ones I've bought lately do not melt. I leave it in a butter dish but even overnight it does not soften up.

Butter has changed... I've used this exclusively for my baked goods and the new formula is messing them up. It doesn't melt as easily and doesn't taste the same and it'svery evident in buttercream. So frustrating!

I love butter. A lot of cheaper store brand butters have a lot of water added to them and so they are not very good to bake with. This is creamy and sweat and low in water content. I drive 20 minutes out of my way yo buy this butter. So good!

Was disappointed Sam's didn't have the regular (4) 1LB solid blocks. That's one of my go-to buys at Sam's. Didn't realize it until I got home, now I'm just stuck with it. UGH.

I use plenty of butter when I cook and bake, especially since margarine is just a molecule away from being plastic. Sam's butter works for me because it's more cost efficient to buy in bulk, and my meals still come out yummy

Quality butter that is typically pretty balanced for baking. Some butters have a very high water content that makes certain recipes/frostings a nightmare. Generally equal to or less than the cost of 4 lbs at Aldi.

I believe the way all butter is made currently has changed drastically. This is not the same product as it was a year or so ago. It's clear how the recipe has changed.

Good value compared to grocery store. I often find I’m buying more than i need at Sam’s. I’m not sure I’m saving enough to compensate for the club membership fee.

Love this butter and love being able to get these in a 4- 1lb packs. If I can't get out to Sam's I end up having to get a 2- 1lb pack. I rather have the 4 pack.