Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Member ratings & reviews for
BUTTERFLY SHRIMP JUMBO MEMBER'S MARK
Sort by |
Showing 31-40 of 232 reviews
Nov 20, 2019
kit
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible

We used to buy these years ago and they were amazing. Not sure what is different but these are flavorless and the shrimp is the size of cocktail shrimp. Wonder if we can return these to get our money back - 1/2 of the package was thrown out. Do no buy!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Apr 3, 2020
Stan47
1 out of 5 stars review

More breading than shrimp

Sam's continues to get rid of a good name brand products and replace it with an inferior Member's Mark one. The breading easily has a 2:1 ratio to shrimp. The Seapak product they replaced was more shrimp than breading. Bring it back and let me chose what I want.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Nov 28, 2019
JSMT
1 out of 5 stars review

NOT THE SAME SHRIMP!

I can't tell you the disappointment when my husband brought these home and I discovered that they are NOT the same Member's Mark Butterfly shrimp. Member's Mark Butterfly Shrimp that we used to get, not too long ago was a true butterfly with a light, seemed like panko breading and they WERE NOT in two bags...they were layed out in the box with wax paper between each layer. Those were delicious...bought them all the time. These remind me of the Seapak brand, just in a Member's Mark box. Wherever Sam's got the original butterfly shrimp and sold them under the Member's Mark name, they should go back to those. Obviously what they are selling now is lesser quality than the original. Please bring the other back!!!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Mar 25, 2020
Rich
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible!

This Member's Mark shrimp is terrible in comparison to the Sea Pack shrimp that I bought for many years at Sam's. I don't object if Sam's wants to offer their own brands of merchandise as an alternative, but don't remove the favorites that customers have purchased for many years. It is getting to the point where I may have to drop my membership if this nonsense continues. The replacement of brand name products with Member's Mark products seems to be permeating the store.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Apr 27, 2020
Lizloveu38
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

GREAT TASTE!!

I bought these butterfly shrimp as quick appetizer for my ladies tv night at my house. The box comes with two bags containing about 12/15 pcs per bag, and good size shrimp for the price. Preparation was in no time, the taste is absolutely amazing and the girls loved them! We have fish every Friday and my husband loves these shrimp with coleslaw and hush puppies as a compliment to his meal. I make my on dipping sauce, but of course you can buy whatever your taste calls for. Buy and enjoy!!!!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Dec 3, 2019
Too LONG Sams Club Member
1 out of 5 stars review

Please Stop Making Everything Members Mark..

I totally agree with the reviews that said very little shrimp and all breading...yuck, yuck, yuck..They taste like nothing compared to SeaPak. Stop trying to reduplicate everything with the Members Mark name if you can't get it right. You're only charging the members the same prices for the lesser quality. Wow, we pay for less than mediocre?

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Apr 29, 2020
JeanieJ
1 out of 5 stars review

Sam's should be facing suit for false advertizing

Very disappointing. There is nothing jumbo about these shrimp. They are very small shrimp disguised in big blanket of breading. Needless to say, what you taste is dry breading with a hint of shrimp flavor. No thanks. Please bring back Sea Pak - JUMBO BUTTERFLY SHRIMP!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Nov 5, 2020
Foodi
1 out of 5 stars review

stop members mark brand

I used to buy these battered shrimp all the time but now since they've switched to members mark they are horrible. The taste isn't the same. Sometimes 2 or 3 shrimp are battered together, or a half of a shrimp is battered. I will no longer purchase these. I've also noticed that they've changed a lot of name brand items that I like to members mark. I will not be renewing my plus membership because members mark is not of good quality.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Dec 28, 2019
yellowjacket1986
1 out of 5 stars review

DO NOT BUY THIS SHRIMP!

If you typically purchase the Sea Pak brand, you will be VERY disappointed in this product. The breading is disgusting, tasteless, too crunchy, too much breading, and the shrimp is small, not jumbo. I can't believe Sam's sells this product to the public. Please don't waste your money!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Jun 9, 2020
Marc K
1 out of 5 stars review

Don't buy this product

I just had these breaded shrimp and they were horrible!!! I followed the directions and we threw most of it away. There was way too much breading and most of it fell off as we were putting it on the plate. The shrimp were small and there was no flavor.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114