Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer ratings & reviews for
BUTTERFLY SHRIMP JUMBO MEMBER'S MARK
Sort by |
Showing 21-30 of 232 reviews
Nov 18, 2019
Donke
3 out of 5 stars review

Ms

I used to buy these when they were sold in 5 pound box. They were the best breaded frozen shrimp that we have tried. Wish they would go back to the original breading, panko, which was much lighter. Shrimp were bigger too. Now, they have a thick breading, which is not panko, my family wouldn't eat them. So, almost $20 bucks down the drain. Don't buy there's. They are terrible.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Apr 29, 2020
JeanieJ
1 out of 5 stars review

Sam's should be facing suit for false advertizing

Very disappointing. There is nothing jumbo about these shrimp. They are very small shrimp disguised in big blanket of breading. Needless to say, what you taste is dry breading with a hint of shrimp flavor. No thanks. Please bring back Sea Pak - JUMBO BUTTERFLY SHRIMP!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Dec 27, 2019
Karen
2 out of 5 stars review

Not what it replaced!

As a fan of many Membership Mark products, I do not hesitate in this case to complain about this one. I reach for the Sea Pack shrimp frequently for my father. This Membership Mark Butterfly "jumbo" shrimp had the same price tag as the Sea Pack but there is absolutely NO comparison in the quality of this. I plan to return the package I bought and will have to buy my breaded shrimp elsewhere!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Jul 23, 2020
Vegas RN
1 out of 5 stars review

Don't Bother

These are new to my Sam's Club. I always bought the SeaPak Breaded Shrimp but Sam's has replaced those with these. These are terrible. Too much breading with chewy, rubbery shrimp. We loved the SeaPak Shrimp. These were such a huge disappointment. Won't be buying again.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Jan 4, 2020
Cookingismypassion
1 out of 5 stars review

Don't waste your time

I haven't bought breaded shrimp at Sam's since they switched to their own brand. The coating is very thick. You can hardly find the shrimp. No flavor what so ever. I did a quick piece count and of course found the higher count which means the shrimp are small. The old brand was excellent with good flavor and light breading. Another bomb in Sam's attempt to bring store brands in to improve their bottom line.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Mar 25, 2020
Rich
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible!

This Member's Mark shrimp is terrible in comparison to the Sea Pack shrimp that I bought for many years at Sam's. I don't object if Sam's wants to offer their own brands of merchandise as an alternative, but don't remove the favorites that customers have purchased for many years. It is getting to the point where I may have to drop my membership if this nonsense continues. The replacement of brand name products with Member's Mark products seems to be permeating the store.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Nov 19, 2020
Jfaries
1 out of 5 stars review

Bad shrimp!

The old Members Mark Jumbo breaded shrimp (had paper dividers between layers) were better than some restaurants served! These new ones taste like Sea Pak freezer burned shrimp. Bring back the old shrimp! I threw away most of this new shrimp; just could not eat it!

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Jun 27, 2020
RP
1 out of 5 stars review

Just don't buy this shrimp

2 Problems Huge amount of breading with tiny (size of a quarter) shrimp Multiple "shrimp" clumped together so it cooks poorly generally awful.... SAMS CLUB buyers please stop selling these and sell Sea Pack instead. If it wasn't such a pain, I would ask for my money back

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Nov 5, 2020
Foodi
1 out of 5 stars review

stop members mark brand

I used to buy these battered shrimp all the time but now since they've switched to members mark they are horrible. The taste isn't the same. Sometimes 2 or 3 shrimp are battered together, or a half of a shrimp is battered. I will no longer purchase these. I've also noticed that they've changed a lot of name brand items that I like to members mark. I will not be renewing my plus membership because members mark is not of good quality.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114
Nov 13, 2020
Gigi
2 out of 5 stars review

You've changed suppliers

I purchased these last week. I have been a consumer of the panko breaded butterfly shrimp from Sam's Club for several years. I have always been satisfied with the quality and taste of the shrimp until now. These are the smallest butterfly shrimp I have ever purchased. Also they are mostly breading. They are just not up to the usual high standards that Members Mark has provided over the years.

Helpful?62B09J47GI3L15348715114