Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
SALTED BUTTER QTRS 1LB - 4 STICKS
4.9 out of 5 stars
stars3,989 ratings3,881 reviews
  1. 5 stars94% (3,757)
  2. 4 stars3% (119)
  3. 3 stars1% (22)
  4. 2 stars1% (24)
  5. 1 star2% (67)

Member photos

  • +129 images
Sort by |
Showing 111-120 of 3,881 reviews
Mar 4, 2024
Kevin
1 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Walmart refuses to let me pick out substitutes unless I download an app. Um no. I will not download something to help a company that doesn't allow me to control my purchases. I did NOT select best match. All "best match" items will be returned and this company will get another low review like they are used to.

Review from walmart.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
Feb 21, 2020
Edward
1 out of 5 stars review

Salted Butter Changes

I know that Land O Lakes has repeatedly said that the recipe hasn't changed but it tastes different now. I noticed it a few months ago. Seems almost a little sour now. I experimented with different bread, then different butter. It was definitely the butter. Not sure why the sour taste to me, wasn't expired or even close. Sorry, I stopped buying it. It's unfortunate because we were raised on your butter and only your butter.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize that the butter tasted sour. Please look for an email from us so we can learn more about your experience.

Feb 16, 2020
Twitter Granny
2 out of 5 stars review

Who changed my butter recipe?

Hello I have been using land o lakes salted sweet cream butter for many years, I'm 60. This new recipe and changes made to the butter is unacceptable, we have come to love the taste and texture of this delicious butter but now you changed it? Please reconsider and revert to the old recipe Please. We the consumers deserve better. Thank you. J. Mitchell

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize you are not happy with taste and texture of the butter you purchased. Thank you for your business. We have not changed our formula. Please look for an email from us.

Aug 24, 2020
Daisy
2 out of 5 stars review

Butter has changed

I have noticed in recent months these changes: The butter crumbles or even shreds (!?) when you try to slice off a pat of butter from the stick. The butter flavor is less distinct, somehow diluted. It seems to lack the high fat texture it always had, as if air was whipped into it or maybe milk instead of cream....

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

Oh no! The butter should not be this way and we have not changed the formulation of this product so we apologize that you are seeing differences. We have emailed you to learn more about your experience.

Aug 31, 2023
Jdub
1 out of 5 stars review

Something has Changed!

I have been a loyal LandOLakes salted stick butter for years! I use it to make butter cookies and frosting. I use It every day to fry eggs and butter toast. But is now different. The cookie dough consistency is different. Eggs fry different. And most obvious is that the stick no longer holds its square shape at room temperature. What have you done to the ingredients???

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize for your recent experience with our butter. Please watch for an email from us with more information.

Nov 22, 2022
Nikk
2 out of 5 stars review

Quality has gone downhill

I have been using Land O Lakes for baking for over 25 years. In recent years, the quality has gone downhill. The butter does not soften correctly and seems to spread too much which really impacts the cookie quality. I am not sure if they changed their recipe. At first, I thought perhaps it was user error but alas, I switched brands and the problem resolved itself.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We value your business. Thank you for your feedback on the butter texture. Please look for an email from us so we can learn more.

Sep 7, 2023
JAS63
1 out of 5 stars review

Higher Price/Poorer Quality

I used to buy Landolakes butter exclusively. Unfortunately, there has been a downward spiral of quality and taste in this butter, while an increase in price. The butter is really greasy and does not have the rich butter taste that it used to have. When I compared it by tasting it and then tasting other brands of butter, the difference was astounding. When I read other reviews on this site, I realized many other customers had come to the same conclusion. Like them, I will no longer be purchasing Landolakes butter.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your long time business and your feedback on the butter texture. Please look for an email from us.

Sep 3, 2019
Goodie
3 out of 5 stars review

Watery?

Have happily used Land O' Lakes butter for decades. Recently the butter seems thin or watery, especially when melted. Sometimes it actually looks like it's separating! When I fry eggs in your butter, it literally pops loudly and spatters me and the stovetop!! After several weeks of this, i decided to write to you. Has something changed - or am I crazy?

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We are sorry you are recently experiencing problems. We have not changed the product formulation. We have sent you an email to learn more.

Apr 19, 2020
Dame
5 out of 5 stars review

Wonderful

The original sweet cream butter is still a staple in so many homes across America! Though it was a bit of a surprise to hear of the recent logo change I applaud your efforts for being a pioneer in today's market and think it's an awesome idea to pay tribute to those hard working dairy farmers that help make this such a terrific product! God bless America!

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
Jun 23, 2023
John from Pennsylvania
4 out of 5 stars review

Plastic Wrapper Ends a Century of Smart Packaging

After being wrapped in compostable wax paper for likely a century, I was greatly disappointed to see your wrapper was changed to a plastic coated alternative. Rather than going to my composter, we now have to throw it into the nonrecyclable, uncompostable plastic-filled trash can. Land-o-Lakes goes backward on sustainability and I'm more than disappointed.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We are sorry for your disappointment with our FlavorProtectâ„¢ Wrapper. This wrapper keeps other flavors out and the fresh taste in. Your comments will be forwarded to our Packaging team.