Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
SALTED BUTTER QTRS 1LB - 4 STICKS
4.9 out of 5 stars
stars3,989 ratings3,881 reviews
  1. 5 stars94% (3,757)
  2. 4 stars3% (119)
  3. 3 stars1% (22)
  4. 2 stars1% (24)
  5. 1 star2% (67)

Member photos

  • +129 images
Sort by |
Showing 121-130 of 3,881 reviews
Jan 24, 2021
Donna
5 out of 5 stars review

Used this product “only” since 1973!

I have used this wonderful salted butter since the early 70's. I use one lb. per week and I am a widow 83 yrs. old. This past two months I have noticed a change in the color, hardness and the taste. Did you change you receipe? It does not taste as buttery. I use no other product and will continue to do so until I cannot live alone or cook anymore

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your email and love to hear that you have enjoyed our butter for so many years. The formula has not changed since 1921 when we started making LAND O LAKES® Salted Butter Sticks from sweet cream and salt. Please watch for an email coming from us soon.

Jun 6, 2020
Charlie
3 out of 5 stars review

What happened!!!

I've been using Land o Lake in my recipes for over 10 years... Approximately a year ago I noticed a change and thought it was my imagination. You had to change the fat content because all my product are different.. What a shame.. I need a specific amount of butter fat for the desired text.. Now I have to change to another butter save my product line....

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your comments about LAND O LAKES® Butter and apologize for any inconvenience you’ve experienced. We have not changed the product formulation. LAND O LAKES® Butter is made from Grade AA sweet cream and salt. To be called "butter," a product must meet the standards outlined in the definition established by the government. Those standards require that butter be made exclusively from milk, cream or both, with or without salt, with or without additional coloring matter, and that it contains not less than 80% milkfat. We apologize that we do not have an explanation for the changes you have noticed. Your feedback will be shared with our Quality Assurance team.

Dec 16, 2023
Barb
2 out of 5 stars review

What has changed?

I just made and baked the same Christmas cookie I've been making for 50 years. When I creamed the butter and the sugar, it never really creams. This has never happened before. The dough was different. They didn't get as big as they usually do. They were harder. They usually melt in your mouth. Also, when i took them out to soften, never got as soft as I needed them after two hours on counter. What is going on??

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize for your experience when making your Christmas cookies this year. We have not intentionally changed our butter recipe. Please watch for an email from us.

Feb 21, 2020
Edward
1 out of 5 stars review

Salted Butter Changes

I know that Land O Lakes has repeatedly said that the recipe hasn't changed but it tastes different now. I noticed it a few months ago. Seems almost a little sour now. I experimented with different bread, then different butter. It was definitely the butter. Not sure why the sour taste to me, wasn't expired or even close. Sorry, I stopped buying it. It's unfortunate because we were raised on your butter and only your butter.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize that the butter tasted sour. Please look for an email from us so we can learn more about your experience.

Feb 23, 2024
LifeIsFaire
1 out of 5 stars review

Packaging deceptive

We have been buying LOL for years recently the packaging has changed and SALTED needs to be more PROMINENT on package! My husband has been eating the WRONG butter for days and is on a sodium controlled diet,under 2000 mg per day and it matters darn it! Salted in small 1 shade off green color band is not sufficient especially since he is color blind and had to view on zoom in website to even see it, totally missed it on package. Saw blue stripe which is traditionally used for only un-salted packages and bought it.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We appreciate your feedback on the packaging and will share with our team. Please look for an email from us. For future reference, unsalted butter sticks are in a blue box.

Dec 16, 2023
Sue S
2 out of 5 stars review

LOL has changed

I've used Land of Lakes for years in all my baking and it always produced good results. Sadly, I am going to have to change brands because your butter has changed, and my bakery is the proof. I've worked in restaurants and have done a lot of baking, so I know what I am talking about. I wish you would return to your original recipe.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We are sorry for your experience as we have not intentionally changed our butter recipe. Please watch for an email from us so we can gather more information.

Sep 11, 2022
Jeannie
1 out of 5 stars review

LOL butter has changed for the worse.

It is the only butter i have ever purchased, but both hubby and i have felt the taste is gone. It has lost its buttery taste and just tastes greasy. Maybe you have switched from grass fed cows? I dont know the answer, but please bring back LOL BUTTER with the old taste. In the meantime i think iwill go with Kerrygold.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize for your experience. Please watch for an email coming from us so we can learn more.

Aug 31, 2023
Jdub
1 out of 5 stars review

Something has Changed!

I have been a loyal LandOLakes salted stick butter for years! I use it to make butter cookies and frosting. I use It every day to fry eggs and butter toast. But is now different. The cookie dough consistency is different. Eggs fry different. And most obvious is that the stick no longer holds its square shape at room temperature. What have you done to the ingredients???

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize for your recent experience with our butter. Please watch for an email from us with more information.

Apr 18, 2020
Slarkin63
2 out of 5 stars review

Watery

I have been an avid user for your butter for years. I have to say the last few boxes I have purchased have not melted the same. Today I went to have fried eggs and you could tell the butter was watery. It was popping at a low temp. I've read that you haven't changed the formula but something has definitely changed.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize that you noticed a texture difference when making your eggs. Please look for an email from us so we can learn more.

Apr 22, 2023
Sanders family
1 out of 5 stars review

Taste has changed

We've used this butter for over 20 years, but something bad has happened to the taste. I thought it might be spoiled, but it's not that as the same bad taste is present in newly purchased sticks, sticks straight from the fridge. Unfortunately, we'll be switching brands because it's now a really awful taste.

Review from landolakes.com
Helpful?1978GOWKJBOW15344465100
reply from Consumer Affairs

We apologize for your experience with the taste and would like to know more. Please look for an email from us. Thank you for your review.