Bro this is so good I put this in the fridge because I kept eating it but then after 2 minutes I got up and ate the whole thing keep it up you never disappoint us.=)

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I like these because they are easy to make .you don't have to pull out a whole bunch of stuff to make cookies I can make them in my air fryer and not heat up my whole house

NASTY!!! Why mess up a great thing!?! I immediately noticed the difference. The cookies were flat and tasteless. Went straight to the garbage. They definitely didn't poke the doughboy for good luck, because these are a FAIL!!

Taste very good however cooking times very and they brown very quickly

I really wanted to like the new recipe, but I don't. No one in my family does. When I made cookies with the old recipe, they disappeared fast. Less than an hour after they came out of the oven, they were gone. I made the "new recipe" chocolate chip cookies three days ago and still have a bag full. That has never happened. I'm afraid to try the sugar. 

Being 100% honest, something definitely tastes “off” with this new recipe. I don't make cookies very often, so tonight I just happened to grab some break and bake from the store to make for a trip with friends this weekend. I had no idea that it was a new recipe, and had not heard about the uproar. I didn't even notice the note on the front about the money back guarantee. I was focused on reading the instructions, and getting these babies on the oven. First batch comes out and cools, and I go to try one. Immediately I just feel it tastes different... not as much flavor maybe? I checked the package to make sure I wasn't missing anything, as they taste like a low fat, or healthy version. Finally noticed the note about recipe change, and that's how I ended up here. Unbiased opinion, had no idea when I ate the first one, and undoubtably knew something was off. :( 

I agree with the majority here. I made a batch and didn't notice the new recipe advertisement, and thought I'd gotten a bad batch! They didn't even cook right! So I got another package and my daughter pointed out the new recipe. We were extremely disappointed! So sad, and wish they would go back to the old recipe! Can't believe they changed such a long standing recipe! I will not buy anymore!

The first time I taste the cookie dough I knew right away it was a nightmare  they've used to have the best cookie dough back then,I've been eating the old recipe since I was a kid and sadly I wont be able to eat it again they need to bring back the old recipe I would give this a zero rating but of course you can't Bring Back The Old Recipe been too long and no one wants the nasty new recipe

I truly do not understand the low reviews!These have truly been the best chocolate chip cookies I've ever had. Perhaps others are over cooking them? They must be cooked so that the bottoms are lightly brown and the tops are stuff puffy-- they will settle while cooling. They are the perfect mix of soft and crunchy when fresh and stay soft for the next couple of days, and are great for dipping in milk- half a cookie at a time, or it will fall apart. I truly love this taste and hope that they don't get rid of this!

Okay, so hear me out, we made the cookie and they were not bad at all. They were warm and actually really good. I like reading reviews and history of products and saw the low reviews are starting reading. I think they should really bring back the old recipe if this many people are upset with the new recipe.