Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Member ratings & reviews for
PINE-SOL PINE 175 FL OZ

Member photos

  • +466 images
Sort by |
Showing 311-320 of 21,859 reviews
Oct 5, 2013
Bookworm
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring back the old pine-sol; this new one stinks literally!!!

When I was a child my mom cleaned with pine-sol and I loved the smell of it! So as an adult, I used pine-sol too. When I went to use it yesterday, I thought that I must have brought a generic brand or something, because it smells so bad it gave me a headache. This one is not "original scent" as it says and it doesn't smell great. Please let me know when the real original one comes back or I won't buy it again.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Jul 18, 2016
cleanfreak
1 out of 5 stars review

New scent is horrible!

I used up an old bottle of original Pine Sol the other day and asked my husband to buy more while he was running errands. Little did I know the formula has changed ... and unfortunately, not for the better. The new scent smells nothing like pine. It has a fragrance more like cheap men's cologne or citronella that immediately resulted in a headache and nausea. I had to open a window and walk outside to keep from getting sick. I'd try one of the other fragrances but prefer the clean smell of natural pine. In addition, the others do not appear to have the same antibacterial qualities. If pine oil is too expensive, please seek other sources ... and/or increase the price ... and/or find a way to make one of the other popular scents antibacterial. Sorry, but the "new" Pine Sol is truly awful.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
reply from Pine-Sol Consumer Services

Hello! We're sorry to hear about your issues with the fragrance. We appreciate you taking the time to share your feedback with us. Please reach out to us at 1-800-227-1860 between 9am-5:30pm EST so we may further assist you with this. Use the reference number 160721-000667 for swift assistance. Thanks in advance!

Oct 24, 2013
sadwoman
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible Scent

I am so upset. I purchased a new bottle of Pine-Sol and the scent is terrible. It is NOT my original scent that I have used and loved for over 42 years! PLEASE- PLEASE give us the original scent back or at least give us a choice. It looks like I will be searching for another product that I know will not be as good as my old faithful-Pine-Sol.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Oct 8, 2016
LongtimeCustomer
2 out of 5 stars review

"Original" Pine-Sol is now mis-labeled

We ran out of our supply of Pin-Sol and restocked at our local supermarket only to find the original scent had been changed. We should have been forewarned on the label. There are few perfumes that I can tolerate...especially artificial scents. They actually nauseate me, and this one lingers and lingers. The original pine scent of Pine-Sol is about the only one I actually enjoy smelling. This new scent is just wrong. We had to give the bottle to a local thrift store in hopes that it might still be useful to someone. I'm sure it still cleans as well as the origianal. I suspect the change was made to increase profit. Well... not from us anymore. I hope someone at Pine-Sol is collecting sales data on the "Original" product. It is used slowly, so a drop in sales may not be immediately evident, but until the label says "Original Pine Scent", we aren't buying.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
reply from Pine-Sol Consumer Services

Thanks for sharing your feedback! We're sorry to hear about your experience with the new scent. We wouldn't expect that to happen and we'd like to hear more. Please reach out to us at 1-800-227-1860 between 9am-5:30pm EST so we can chat further. Use the reference number 161010-000463 for swift assistance. We look forward to assisting you!

Sep 2, 2013
Hate the smell.
1 out of 5 stars review

The new smell is horrid

I have tried to send you a private comment but the comment site does not work (it will not let you put in a product, and will not accept the message without the product). This is also my second attempt to post a comment about the new "longer lasting smell." You rejected my comment based on non-specific guideline violation. Other than that I criticized the smell, I have no idea what the problem was. I also stated I loved and used the original pine sol for 35 years. Perhaps you only like happy face comments? Please send me an email with a phone number or email of someone I can communicate with.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Dec 27, 2013
AnitaMichaelS
2 out of 5 stars review

Used to smell Awesome....now not so much :(! Please bring back the real original scent!!

I used to use Pine-Sol original all the time! It reminded me of my childhood plus it smelled wonderful! But I just can't use the new one... the smell gives me a headache! It makes me sad to not be able to smell the glorious familiar scent that I've grown accustomed to! Please bring back the real original!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Dec 16, 2013
marys
1 out of 5 stars review

Please go back to the orignal scent

the new longer lasting scent is dreadful. I bought a second bottle just to see if maybe after 30 years of buying this stuff i got a bad batch but nooooo the company really has changed the scent. Change it back, change it back, change it back, please.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Sep 13, 2013
Disappointed with the New Pine Sol Original
1 out of 5 stars review

Dislike the new Pine Sol Original Scent

I am so disappointed with the new smell and reformulation of Original Pine Sol. I grew up with my mother using the old formula. When I became an adult, that's what I used also. Today I cleaned with the new formula and it has an awful musty smell. My teens also commented how bad it is. They love the old smell too. The new formula does not clean well. It does not leave that fresh clean airy scent. You will loose a lot of customers if you don't bring it back!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Feb 6, 2014
Dog Mom
3 out of 5 stars review

New Scent

I'm sorry, I don't like the new scent. I didn't know it was changed until I used it. It was really noticeable. There is such a strong chemical scent, not the pleasant scent of the original. I thought I bought the wrong kind. Sorry about the lack of pine oil that you are having. I had to let you know my thoughts on it. I can't use it. I am sorry because I love your company and want to support it.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Feb 21, 2014
Sandy
3 out of 5 stars review

Original Pine-sol

I miss the original smell. After years of using the original and switching to the new scent... It's not the same great smell. The new smell does not smell as good. When I wanted something different, I always switched to lemon or lavender! I hope you bring back the original scent. I really miss the smell! I hope you can bring back the original scent which is an old favorite of mine!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458