Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Member ratings & reviews for
PINE-SOL PINE 175 FL OZ
4.7 out of 5 stars
stars21.9K ratings21.8K reviews
  1. 5 stars82% (17.9K)
  2. 4 stars15% (3,247)
  3. 3 stars1% (322)
  4. 2 stars0% (85)
  5. 1 star2% (371)

Member photos

  • +466 images
Sort by |
Showing 251-260 of 21,857 reviews
Sep 23, 2013
EX PINE SOL USER
1 out of 5 stars review

New improved formula is horrible!!

New pine sol literally gave me a headache from the strong nauseating scent. It smelled like that other horrible cleaner Fabuloso. I used it once and never again. I gave the practically new bottle to my mom, she hated it as well. It ended up being poured down the drain. I've used it for years and since my childhood it reminds me of my grandmother. Sad to say, I will no longer purchase the new pine sol. Extremely disappointed, what a shame. Please go back to original formula, nothing out there compares to it.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Dec 11, 2013
craf123
1 out of 5 stars review

The 'New' Scent is gross

I have used Pine-Sol for years. I just bought a bottle, which is labeled just like the 'Original' Pine-Sol. The product is the same color as the original pine scented Pine-Sol. BUT it is not a PINE scent, but some gross perfume-y, overpowering smell. The bottle reeks, even when closed. The bottle is deceptive. It has the same 'Original' label, and a small red 'NEW' buried in it. Why mess with something that works. The NEW smell is the most disgusting, overpowering, bad smell ever. What happened to your Original pine smell. I will not purchase your product again. I will stay with the house-brand Pine cleaner. It is what your 'Original' product was for years. I know you won't post this. BUT you should go back to the PINE scent and dump the perfumes.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Nov 30, 2013
Reemac
1 out of 5 stars review

Original Pine-sol, was my favorite cleaner!!!!!! not the new longer lasting.....not the same.

I have used pine-sol, the original scent, (NOT THE NEW LONGER LASTING SCENT) all my life. The smell made you remember your childhood. But not know, I do not like the new longer lasting scent. It smells too much like turpentine. The original scent pine-sol would get a 5 star rating, & I would recommend it to everyone..... the new longer lasting scent one about 1/2 star & I would not recommend it. Please bring back the original!!!!!!!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Nov 10, 2013
Loyal for Years
1 out of 5 stars review

PLEASE BRING BACK OUR OLD PINE-SOL!!!!

The "new" original scent is nothing like our old favorite. We have all been loyal customers of yours for many generations. Now we are all in the market for a new product to clean our homes. This move will not make us chose one of the other scents offered. If that was the case we would not be so upset about this change. Please hear us and make this right. If my great grandmother was here she would say the same thing. The "new" scent makes my home smell like a chemically cleaned hospital.. there is nothing pleasant or comforting about it....

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Dec 30, 2013
Dove
1 out of 5 stars review

I used to love Pine-sol

I've been using it for years and got the tradition from my grandmother who used it in her home. But I was disappointed after trying the new formula. It is more sudsy and the scent is fake. I visited the website hoping to find a way to purchase the original formula Pine-Sol but it looks like it is gone.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Aug 13, 2021
Twinkletots
5 out of 5 stars review

The OG of Household Cleaners

I can remember as a child growing up that on Saturday mornings if I would smell Pine-Sol I knew mama was up and at it cleaning. I find myself the same way now and hope my kids will do the same. I guess you can say that pine-sol is a generational choice!!!!

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Oct 31, 2013
TMF18
1 out of 5 stars review

It made me literally sick

I have chemical sensitvities and could only use pine-sol to clean my floors safely. The old formula was something I could handle. My husband just bought the new pine-sol...which said it was the same old formula, and my daughter mopped with it. I came home and had to go outside immediately! They are now trying to mop again with just water to see if they can get rid of the smell and chemical. I can't even begin to tell you how upsetting this is for me. I need Pine-sol the way it used to be. PLEASE change it back. I can't use something that makes me sick. I suppose I'll have to figure out how to make my own floor cleaner now. We're going to return the bottle. So sad that you all would mess with something that so many people depend on.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Jan 30, 2014
Momofmany
1 out of 5 stars review

I am distraught and disappointed!

I purchased the new "longer lasting scent" Pinesol the other day... It's awful...why fix something that doesn't need to be fixed? Bring back the old scent... I think you will keep your business going, if not you will find all of us "faithful family" Pinesol users out searching elsewhere, and that is a scary thought because original Pinesol has been around forever and I don't think anything can replace it. The new scent smells like cheap bathroom spray:-( Please bring back the old scent...Then I will give 50 stars! :-)

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Mar 1, 2013
Loves2clean
3 out of 5 stars review

Changed formula

I just purchased a new bottle of Original Pine Sol. My old bottle has been around awhile. When did you change the formula. It's thinner and no longer has a laundry recommendation. The old bottle had active ingredient: Pine Oil; the new bottle active ingredient has:Glycolid Acid? Why the change to a good product?

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458
Nov 10, 2013
Anonymous
2 out of 5 stars review

Bring back the "original" scent.

I recently purchased a new bottle of original Pinesol only to find that they've changed the "original" to a new scent advertised to last longer. Trouble is, it stinks and I can't wait for it to go away. I've always enjoyed the scent of the original formula and can't stand the heavy axe-body-spray-esque scent. I'm not even sure I can stand using the rest of the the huge bottle I invested in.

Review from pinesol.com
Helpful?1M8FKMUI3WZ815315553458