My dog Ginger loves these. Give her one every afternoon to help keep her teeth clean. She gets excited when I pick up the container! They don't smell appetizing for me, but I don't plan on eating them.

Our dog LOVE these! First cleaning treat they enjoy!

my dogs love this. They generally use another brand, but I thought I'd try these.

Not rebuying due to smell

My dog enjoys them, but they smell terrible! They're similar to bully sticks, so you have to be mindful where your dog eats them.

My Sheltie had one and nearly choked to death. He couldn't breathe. I got it out of his throat and it was so gooy and the entire contained stunk like u know what. I was immediately refunded, no questions asked and I now understand why.

Choking hazard! Scared to find that these are actually dangerous. For some reason, one of my dogs chokes on these because they become so gummy once she starts chewing on them. She's an 8 pound dachshund so I don't know if it's just dangerous for smaller dogs. (My 12 pound poodle didn't have the choking problem with these treats.) Bummer.

Dog (standard poodle) could not digest these and vomits them up.

Made my dogs vommit and had a foul odor.

These SMELL disgusting. Think fish that accidentally got left in a cooler for a week bad.