Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Califia Farms Extra Creamy Oatmilk (48 oz., 2 pk.)
Sort by |
Showing 21-30 of 209 reviews
Oct 9, 2023
KJ28
1 out of 5 stars review

Tastes like dirt

This is absolutely horrible. I've tried so many oat milks and never had one so bad. Based on all these good reviews I'm wondering if i got a bad bottle bc i hadTo throw it out it was so awful

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Aug 30, 2022
Anonymous
5 out of 5 stars review

Great for everything in the morning!

I enjoyed this in my coffee, my kids enjoyed as their morning milk and in on their cereal and then I also used it in a recipe and for overnight oats and was not disappointed! If it can go in my coffee and be frothed and work to start my morning, that is good enough for me, but our whole family enjoyed it.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Aug 25, 2023
ColM
1 out of 5 stars review

Do not buy

This is easily the worst oak milk out there. It has an off-putting taste like pea protein or something, maybe it's trying to be malty but it tastes like I'd imagine burnt barley would. I'm normally able to stomach most milks but this is just awful and I ended up returning it. Califia is usually a good quality, good tasting company, but this product is a huge miss.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Aug 22, 2021
Caspaqutie
5 out of 5 stars review

Clean tasting oat milk

I have been using Califia almond milk for years. It's clean tasting and minimal ingredients. I was excited when they started making oat milk. As always, Califia did not disappoint! The oat milk also has a clean, not overpowering taste. I add it to my coffee and it adds a little something to the flavor without being too heavy or strong. I love this brand and will alternate between their almond and oat!!!

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Mar 18, 2021
Theodore
3 out of 5 stars review

Good oatmilk, poor packaging

I enjoy this oatmilk more than other brands, and I would buy this product all the time if not for the packaging: Because of the long neck and round body, a 48-ounce bottle takes up more refrigerator space than other brands' 64-ounce bottles. The large, heavy, non-recyclable cap generates more plastic waste than necessary. On the plus side, the label is fairly easy to remove so the bottle can be recycled.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
reply from Customer Care

Thank you for taking the time to write a review and for your honest feedback. We suggest checking out our Oat Barista Blend, it's in a 32oz Tetra Pak/carton.

May 27, 2024
Eri32
1 out of 5 stars review

Taste has gotten worse

I've used this with my coffee for several years. They said the ingredients didn't change with the new packaging but I swear it tastes horrible now.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Aug 12, 2023
laninadelclub
1 out of 5 stars review

Bad taste!

I bought this at Walmart in 08/05/23 for the first time and has a taste like oil, car oil and has a very acid and strong smell like vinegar and plastic, the expiration date is 12/06/23, I don't know why :(

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Jan 5, 2021
KeepItSimple
1 out of 5 stars review

Nope. yuck.

Purchased as a replacement by a grocery delivery service, this was my first Califia Farms Oat milk experience and so disappointing. Why is there SUNFLOWER OIL in this? It's all I taste, other than the salt. Does not taste anything like oak milk.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
reply from Customer Care

Hi, this is not the experience that our customers have come to expect from our products. A member of our Customer Care team will follow up via email to learn more and replace your purchase

Jul 22, 2021
Eve618
5 out of 5 stars review

Best yet, but....

After much searching, yours is the best tasting oatmilk I've found. Is there any chance of you going organic, and non GMO? I'm very concerned about pesticides and GMOs, so I'm still searching for an oatmilk that does not contain them.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
May 25, 2023
Supershopper
1 out of 5 stars review

Oat milk

I really wish they would stop running out of silk or planet oat. No way they in 2 months vacaville hadn't restocked its like they arr forcing this on us

Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733