Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Califia Farms Extra Creamy Oatmilk (48 oz., 2 pk.)
Sort by |
Showing 11-20 of 209 reviews
Sep 5, 2024
AshleyM1014
1 out of 5 stars review

Something has changed

Something is off with the taste the last few times I've bought it. I've been buying this oat milk for months go through probably a bottle a week. I bought it a few weeks ago and the logo was darker but I didn't think anything of it. I brought it home and tasted it and it had a terrible taste. I went to another store and bought it again, it had a lighter logo and it tasted fine. I have continued buying the one with the lighter logo for a few weeks and it's been fine until the other day. Same light logo but terrible taste like the darker logo yet they are the same oat milk. It's disgusting and ruins the taste of the coffee. I guess I'll have to find an alternative.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Oct 4, 2024
Nondairyafficiando
1 out of 5 stars review

Do not buy

Clearly a quality issue - this bottle that doesn't expire until three months from now, yet has the most rancid horrible taste I have ever experienced in my 20 years of drinking plantmilk. Shame on the company for not addressing this over the years - I can see similar reviews from the last three or more years with identical complaints. If I hadnt't already been familiar with the company's delicious tasting products and this had been my first time buying from them. I would not be a repeat customer.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Sep 8, 2023
Tanya R
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Great Substitute for Whole Milk!

Creamy and Delicious! A great substitute for Whole Milk

Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Aug 4, 2022
Brady
1 out of 5 stars review

What even is this?

I love other brands of oat milk and this one has very professional packaging so I thought I'd give it a try. Horrendous flavour. A weird salty/savoury tang taste. I checked, it was still two months before the expiry date. It tasted like they had mixed in one of the flavour packets you get in a package of ramen noodles. Don't waste your money, unless you like milk that tastes like old chicken soup rather than oats.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Feb 17, 2026
Rod K
1 out of 5 stars review

no seed oil

i wish if you have another oil instead of sunflower oil... you used to have another bottle with no seed oil in it but i can't seem to find it anymore

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
May 16, 2023
Sandi
2 out of 5 stars review

Don't like the oily aftertaste from the sunflower oil. Won't buy this again. Please bring back Planet Oat brand.

Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
May 23, 2023
tenthrow
3 out of 5 stars review

Okay I guess, but not as good as the other brand

The previous brand carried in the clubs was much better. This has a strange taste under the main oat milk flavor.

Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Dec 1, 2025
BronxBaddie1997
5 out of 5 stars review

The Best Thing Created

I love this milk and buy it religiously. I will never need dairy again between this and country crock plant butter. Always sold out where I am.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Mar 27, 2023
Honi721
1 out of 5 stars review

Be Foreal

This is the nastiest “oak milk” I've ever had tastes worse than almond milk. First and last time buying from this brand. It literally tastes nothing like oak just oil.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Sep 28, 2020
kulkarm
1 out of 5 stars review

Bad smell/taste

I had to throw away the coffee I made with this oat milk! The smell is terrible and the taste is musty as well... not sure if I got a bad batch but I'll be throwing away my bottle.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
reply from Customer Care

Hi, this is not the experience that our customers have come to expect from our products. A member of our Customer Care team will follow up via email to learn more and replace your purchase.