Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Member ratings & reviews for
Califia Farms Extra Creamy Oatmilk (48 oz., 2 pk.)
Sort by |
Showing 1-10 of 209 reviews
Dec 9, 2025
KathyB
5 out of 5 stars review

Simply the best

For years I have tried different milk substitute products Before this oat milk/almond milk/coconut milk there was only soy milk. The best soy milk - far superior to any on the market today - was Eden Soy. Now comes the wave of oat milks.Califia is - to my taste buds - the most satisfying and delicious. SADLY however the creamy version of their oat milk is the most popular and the zero sugar is almost extinct in the stores- I look for it everywhere! But all in all Califia is far superior to Oatley and any others. Unfortunately the markets seem to favor Oatley.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Mar 26, 2020
Not ur average human
5 out of 5 stars review

The closet thing to whole milk

Whoa! You won't believe it but this is the real deal. I'm allergic to almonds, so no almond milk for me. Plus ew. I don't like coconut milk way too watery. Soy makes me want to throw up. I was very hesitant to try this but thought hey why not. Thank goodness I did. I don't want to give my baby cows milk. So I was desperately looking for an alternative. This is it. Question: is it safe for 1 year olds. I should ask my pediatrician. Either way, when my little one is able to drink this. He will love it because his mom does. So glad I took the chance. Also, I'm a sucker for good packaging. No weird taste. No weird after taste. Great with cereal. Great cold or warmed.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Feb 21, 2025
livollyolive_5787
4 out of 5 stars review

High quality and tastes great but pricey

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Taste great and texture is smooth. Great for mixing with my iced coffees! It is a bit on the pricey side and doesn't stand out compared to cheaper options so I probably will not buy again.

Review from influenster.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Sep 6, 2025
Bongo88
2 out of 5 stars review

Doesn't froth

Very disappointed that this does not froth at all for my specialty coffee! I've used many different non-dairy beverages over the years, and this one, unfortunately, doesn't pass.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Sep 2, 2025
Dizalmonds
2 out of 5 stars review

Oatmill yum

Forget Califya. Overcharging is a crime. It's oats. And it's not even organic. Califia farms (that's a joke) boooooo!

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Dec 31, 2025
Matcha matcha
2 out of 5 stars review

I can taste the oil

I can taste the oil taste and see the oil dots floating in the product. It truly disturbed the taste of my matcha. I have had success with other brands but tried Califia farms due to a sale. This was not a good fit for me.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
May 15, 2020
Barton
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible taste.

This really tastes like they filtered it through old carpet. There is a very musty smell coming from it and the taste is equally musty. This isn't the first oat milk I've tried so I know it's not supposed to taste like that. Actually the first almond milk I tried was this brand so maybe I don't really hate almond milk, just the stuff these guys put in it. I'm honestly going to have to dump it out and buy something else.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
reply from Customer Care

Oh no! We're sorry to hear about your experience with our product. Your description certainly doesn't meet our standards of quality. Look out for an email from our Customer Care team, so that we can try to make it up to you.

May 23, 2023
solstes
1 out of 5 stars review

Not good!

We bought this because Sam's keep running out of Planet Oat Milk (my son cannot have almonds and ect) and my son wanted milk and so we were left with no other choice. While it is edible, it has a bad after taste. Its just not good! I wish Sam's could keep Planet Oak in stock.

Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
Jan 9, 2021
amanda03
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible!

I bought this because I have been trying out several oat milks to see which ones are the best out there. This one is the absolute WORST one I've had. The smell is horrible, it weirdly smells like musty bread. So odd, as it is gluten free. The taste is also horrible and ruined my iced latte. This is the only oat milk I've actually disliked. I'm so disappointed because I was really excited to try it and was expecting to love it.

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733
reply from Customer Care

Hi, this is not the experience that our customers have come to expect from our products. A member of our Customer Care team will follow up via email to learn more and replace your purchase.

Nov 10, 2025
Apples
1 out of 5 stars review

Califia farms extra creamy Oatmilk

I've been using this oatmilk for over a year and a half and I just purchased a bottle the other day and it has this oily film on the top now, never did before, What's going on with this, should I be worried about my health???

Review from califiafarms.com
Helpful?2XG1F3Y357TD15270673733