Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Member ratings & reviews for
COUNTRY CROCK SPREAD 3.75 LB.

Member photos

  • +476 images
Sort by |
Showing 61-70 of 6,172 reviews
Nov 10, 2015
thatsroxie
1 out of 5 stars review

Why do people always try to change a good thing.

I, the same as sooooo many others, hate this "new recipe". It is honestly just horrible. I do not really understand how the companies taste testers actually thought this product tasted better than the true original. Once again last night I went to make one of my favorite dinners which usually included Original Country Crock or the Added Calcium version. I couldn't even finish it. Starting today I am on the hunt for a new brand. Really disappointed. While I search I will be watching and really hoping that Country Crock realizes the huge mistake they made and go back to what has worked for them all these years.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Mar 14, 2016
KrushingIT
1 out of 5 stars review

Loved the previous recipe

I used to be a huge fan of Country Crock, but I no longer like the new recipe. It does not melt right, and the flavor is off. Bring back the old version. We will all be happier for it. I received (or will receive) compensation/free product for my unbiased review.

Review from influenster.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Nov 17, 2015
BrookAA
1 out of 5 stars review

New recipe is so gross!!

I have been using country crock for 31 years. The new recipe is so gross. I knew immediately something was off. I will never buy it again. I am so devastated this is a huge deal....I have become so desperate for the original that I've tried looking to see if I can buy it online. They need to go back to the original recipe again.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Aug 5, 2015
mlw5
1 out of 5 stars review

New Simple Recipe is awful!

We've used the original country crock for years. Bought the 'New Simple Recipe'. It tastes absolutely horrible!!! Even when we put it in a frying pan to cook with it, the smell was horrible! We've always loved the original country crock. We've used it for over 15 years. We will stop buying this product and will try something else. We just can't stand the taste of it.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Nov 1, 2015
Jan70
1 out of 5 stars review

The Title is fine - The container is fine

The product is terrible!!! Hate the new taste and if they don't change it back to the original recipe, I'll be looking for a new margarine. I am so disappointed - All these years. Why fix something what wasn't even broken??? It was wonderful and I used it for everything I made. Who needed butter when you had Country Crock?

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Jul 24, 2015
Dsums
1 out of 5 stars review

Awful!

I have been using Country Crock for years and loved it. I bought the new container and thought it was the same recipe just different packaging. The new recipe tastes awful and I will be returning my tub to the store for a refund. I will never buy this again. Time to find a good tasting butter. So sad!

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Feb 23, 2016
lmk911
1 out of 5 stars review

New Simple Recipe not good

I have loved Country Crock Original forever, but the "New Simple Recipe" used on the "original" product is not good. The taste is off and it affects the taste of all the foods I prepare with it. There is nothing "original" about it, it is a new product entirely that does not taste nearly as good as the Country Crock I've known and loved.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Aug 21, 2015
ANNIE2698
1 out of 5 stars review

Once Great and now dreadful!

I am very particular when it comes to margarines/spreads because I despise the taste of butter. Have a hard time finding a margarine because plenty of them taste like butter. When I found Country Crock "original" I fell in love! Now apparently the shape of the tub has been changed so that it is easier to fit in a refrigerator. I opened it up and spreaded it on my bagel as I do every morning, took one bite and spit it out and also threw out the bagel. Why would you change the taste? There are different varieties, i.e. calcium, churn style, etc., which all have a different taste than the original, all of which I can't eat because those do have a buttery taste. Now this simple recipe tastes just like the other styles. Please bring the real original back!

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Jan 22, 2016
Cougar
1 out of 5 stars review

New Coke

Taste is not good. Does not spread like the old recipe. I have gone through two tubs and nobody in my family can not stand the taste. So I am leaving what use to be a good product and trying other products till I can find something that my family likes. Since the change in the recipe of this product it has changed the taste of everything we use it in and not for the better. I have gotten complaints on my cooking because of how the food item would taste, would be asked what had I changed and please to go back to the old recipe. The only thing I had changed was using your new product instead of the old product.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Aug 21, 2015
Mrsklove
1 out of 5 stars review

Horrible taste

If I could give this 0 stars I would. I have used this butter for as far back as I could remember. But yesterday will be my last purchase. This tastes horrible. It makes food taste funny and my children, who will eat anything, refused to eat the French toast because it tasted bad. I will unfortunately have to look for a new butter to use.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527