Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
Member ratings & reviews for
COUNTRY CROCK SPREAD 3.75 LB.

Member photos

  • +476 images
Sort by |
Showing 121-130 of 6,172 reviews
Jul 9, 2017
JamieManous
1 out of 5 stars review

New Recipe is Horrible

Why change a good thing. If it aint broke dont fix it! The last 2 tubs i bought are horrible with the "new" recipe. It tastes so nasty now after using Country crock my whole life i now havr to find a new brand. This stuff is just nasty. It will not firm up in the fridge yet wont melt on toast. I thought the first one i bought was just bad and bought another to find it the same nasty soft watery junk. I then noticed it was "new" and disgusting. No more country crock for me

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Sep 3, 2015
Capt Ron
1 out of 5 stars review

They blew a good thing

We have used Country Crock butter for as long as I can remember. We loved the taste and spreadability. Recently we had to purchase more, and bough the "new" Country Crock. We happened to be having corn on the cob that night. we tried the new spread and immediately saw a huge difference. It intermediately melted to the consistence of water in our plate. Upon trying it, the taste that we had enjoyed for years was gone. Thinking it was the corn, we got out a tub of the old Country Crock. It was not the corn. The spreadability and taste was what we remembered and expected. It is a shame that we have to look for a new butter replacement.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Aug 10, 2015
DaveE
1 out of 5 stars review

ZERO Stars. Don't call it Original. It's not.

I've used this for 20 years. Now it's time to find another brand. This new taste is awful. At first I thought my taste was off. But everyone in my home says the same thing. We have thrown out food we cooked with this spread. I keep trying it hoping it will get better, but it doesn't. Sorry Country Crock, this new taste doesn't work.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Sep 17, 2015
Soulpink
1 out of 5 stars review

Aweful

I hate the new recipe. I have been a loyal fan of this product. I will have to go buy another spread. My family did not like it. We want the old country Crock back. You are going to loose a lot of business . The taste is aweful . Will not be buying this spread again .

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Jul 3, 2016
Autisim Dad
1 out of 5 stars review

Why change something good?

I have an autistic child that eats very few things, and one of them is toast. He loves to have toast for breakfast before school. The only butter that he likes is the original Country Crock in the round tub. He hates the New Simple Recipe, tried it once and now he no longer eats toast for breakfast. In fact most days he does not eat breakfast anymore, just a glass of milk. We all tried it and no one in the family liked it. Its sad that this happened. I do not know the motives behind the change to the New Simple Recipe, and understand the desire to improve your products, but why eliminate the old recipe? Would it be too much to ask to offer both old and new recipes?

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Mar 14, 2016
KrushingIT
1 out of 5 stars review

Loved the previous recipe

I used to be a huge fan of Country Crock, but I no longer like the new recipe. It does not melt right, and the flavor is off. Bring back the old version. We will all be happier for it. I received (or will receive) compensation/free product for my unbiased review.

Review from influenster.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Feb 16, 2016
LisaG
1 out of 5 stars review

Bring back the REAL original

I used to put country crock on everything. I loved it more than regular butter. This new original formula is the absolute worst! It makes it seem like the butter is sour. I wish they didn't mess with the original flavor and in turn created a new flavor for this horrible excuse for butter. I'm so heartbroken, I can never have the delicious taste of the REAL original country crock ever again. Won't be buying this again.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Aug 17, 2015
Raklor
1 out of 5 stars review

New "original" reciepe tastes bad

Ive bought country crock for over 15 years and it has been my go to spread in that time. What you are now passing off as original reciepe tastes nothing like the country crock i know and loved and is actually quite disgusting. Bring back the real original if you ever want any more of my money.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Aug 24, 2015
nicole
1 out of 5 stars review

ruined my families dinner

Very disappointed, after cooking a feast for my family everything tasted wrong. The corn, mac n cz, mashed potatos, cake was all blah just as if I would use one of the many other nasty non butters on the shelf. Tried again the next day and my son would not eat his pancakes because he said the butter was yucky ( he is only 5 and noticed). For many years I have bought and encourage others to use your products at this point I feel that it is time for me to shop for a new company. With us being weeks out from holiday cooking this new original recipe is just not going to make the cut. My family recpies will never taste the same and that makes me really sad.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527
Jul 28, 2017
dyoung
1 out of 5 stars review

What happened

I have been a loyal customer of country crock since I was a teen. I even got my in laws to use. it. Every person I've talked to that has tasted the new formula has agreed its horrible. It was embarrassing to my wife for making cookies for a friends party and people hated them. They used to be a hit.

Review from countrycrock.com
Helpful?1E6PI52DIE2115246260527