All my dogs, 3 of them, LOVE these and cannot get enough of them. I know they were a one time deal from members mark, but these NEED to be a regular item moving forward. My sheltie can be a picky eater and I tried many treats before I found these and now it's a must in our house because he loves them as much as the other two. If you're training a puppy, or looking for something for food motivated pups, these are guaranteed to work. Seriously Sam's make these a regular item!

Dog's love it. Good Price.

Nice size ,simi soft , My dogs love them

OK snack - hard for my littlw ones to chew with linited teeth

Skyler loves these and she is very picky.

Dog love them, seem fresh, easy to toss to dogs.

I have 3 dogs and only one dog liked them

My dogs love these. I was buying other yreats st sams but they wete notbthere so i purchased these.

Soft snack for older dogs

Pups new favorite!!! Looks exactly as shown on bag. Smells good and pups love them!