Skip to Main Content
Sams Club
Sams Club
Customer reviews for Member's Mark 35" Barrel Charcoal Grill w/ Cover for
Member's Mark 35" Barrel Charcoal Grill w/ Cover
4.5 out of 5 stars
stars131 ratings54 reviews
  1. 5 stars76% (99)
  2. 4 stars13% (17)
  3. 3 stars1% (1)
  4. 2 stars3% (4)
  5. 1 star8% (10)

Member photos

Sort by |
Showing 21-30 of 54 reviews
Mar 30, 2026
RON
5 out of 5 stars review

Best grill on the market. Big open cooking area. Steel heavy duty grates! Set up takes a little concentration. Also removed secondary chrome rack, just got in the way. Easy to clean, no nonsense. Charcoal tray is taking a beating, but we leave bbq outside. A little rust outside on top, to be expected. Will use black bbq spray paint to cover, very easy. We always use a charcoal chimney with lump charcoal, lighting isperfect every time.

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Jun 13, 2025
Jessica
1 out of 5 stars review

Missing & broken pieces

Received brand new with broken & missing pieces. Company didn't resolve, said not sure what they can do!!! Really???

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Mar 13, 2026
JESSE
2 out of 5 stars review

signs of wear for just 1 year and 10 uses

It shows a lot of wear and tear for being only a year old and used only about 10 times. It's been kept under my shed with a rain and dust cover the whole time. The reason it's wearing out is the very thin sheet metal; it's really not worth almost $199. tax , I regret not choosing something more durable. (Keep in mind that I always clean out the ashes after every use)

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Mar 23, 2026
CHRISTOPHER
4 out of 5 stars review

It would be great if there was a left side fire box attachment to be purchased for it. That would enable a smoker functionality for this grill, which would make it all-in-one perfect, for cooks who don't use gas.

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Apr 14, 2026
anonymous
2 out of 5 stars review

I was excited about my purchase, but some parts were missing and another part didn't fit due to its cut. I wouldn't buy the same product again. I sent an email to customerservice@sumxing.com and I hope for a prompt response and solution.

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Nov 21, 2025
Gregory
5 out of 5 stars review

I read BBQ_Dad's review and realized I had the EXACT same experience! 1) yes you need some intuition on assembly, holes dont always match up, and it needs leg levelers, but like bbqdad, I use a tile under one of the legs.2) the grates last about 2 years. 3) after 4 years, the bottom of the charcoal tray rusted out, I rigged a makeshift fix with some tin, but removing the ashes is now pretty messy job. BOTTOM LINE: This is an excellent and dependable charcoal grill. it's direct heat and it's hard to keep the heat down, but like bbqdad, I bought a pellet grill for slow cooking ribs, etc. IT WOULD BE GREAT if they offered replacement parts, you'd never need another grill!

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Jul 15, 2024
Dano
1 out of 5 stars review

Poor grate quality

I bought this grill about a month ago and had it delivered. When I opened the package I found 2 of the 3 grill grates broken. The material used on the grates was not good quality and would probably would have broken after a summers use. I would not recommend this product unless they improve on the material used to make the grates. The rest of the grill appeared solid but had many pieces to put together, I was able to return it to my local store with no issues

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
May 14, 2025
BBQ_Dad
4 out of 5 stars review

Excellent grill!

I got this 4 years ago it's been a great grill. It's direct heat, hard to keep the temp down but that's fine, I have a pellet grill for slow cooking, It's a good, reliable grill, plenty of room and the front and side shelves are nice. A note on assembly: the bad reviews are mostly related to parts or holes not aligning, etc, This is one of those assemblies where you have to use a little intuition, you may have to redo a step or two to get it right, I'm now going to lie, not the easiest assembly, but it worked, When you finish it, it may wobble a bit, I just put a tile under a leg to level it up a bit, A screw in leveler would be handy, but no big deal. over time the porcelain coated started coming off the cast iron grill surface grates, I replaced them, and the charcoal tray rusted out after about 3 years. Still a great grill well worth the price!

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Jul 5, 2024
Robin
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

Grill

Best investment for grilling

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905
Jul 3, 2024
Josette
5 out of 5 stars review

Verified Purchase

What a great gift!

The grill is much bigger for the next backyard party!

Helpful?6W1ZA8L8TJ0M15057501905