Pie was great, but I gave it a 4 star because it is difficult to visit the store and find a pie that has a "use by date" of more than a day or two. Hard to eat such a nice large pie in one day. I looks like the store bakes too many pies for any given day. This happens a lot. I like my pie fresh as possible.

Crust is good, but the inside contents of the pie are a mushy puree. Do not think you will be getting a pie with visable cherrys that looks delicious. More like baby food. Couldn't finish one piece. Drive is far to be returning it so trash it will go

I’m not typically a cherry pie lover but I bought one for a friend who was coming to to town for a visit. It was absolutely delicious. The crust was perfect and just the right amount of cherries to sauce in the filling. It was even on sale this month. I will definitely buy it again.

I don't understand how people compare this to their grandmother's cherry pie, only way that could be if grandmother lived next to a Hostess overstock store. It tastes like a giant Hostess cherry pie. Don't have to worry that these have to be in season as one reviewer stated because the filling comes from giant cans. Glad it was on sale.

delicious beyond believe. omg first time trying cherry pie like this. this is a pie to recommend and i do. flavor is consistent. you have actual cherries that are flavorful and burst in your mouth. the filling is fresh and the perfect amount of sweetness 😍. my biggest regret is why didnt i try this before.

The cherry pie is not nearly as good as it once was. Too much crust and not enough cherries, the puree filling sucks! At one time Sam's had a great cherry pie, not the case any longer. I will not buy another cherry pie from Sam's Club....does not taste all that great whatsoever! Too bad, at one time Sam's made the best cherry pies.

Nasty, very few cherries, mostly goopy cherry sauce, inedible, threw it away

Best cherry pie ive had in a very long time. Ate it all by myself.

Really good! Was surprised

Wish there were more cherries and less cherry filling.