Good quality cherry pie: crust that is substantial but not soggy, filling that is an excellent consistency, and plenty of fruit. I believe at about $10.00 it is also a great deal. Two pounds of cherries nearly cost that-they still have to add all the other ingredients and make some profit. Also the cherry pie is the perfect family size!

You know I can't believe that they even make a cherry pie! They used to make it and then after the pandemic I don't know why they stopped making it was only apple! But they do make the best cherry pie 🍒🥧😎

It is hard to pass up this pie while I’m shopping. It is so delicious with a flaky crust and delicious cherry filling. I highly recommend this cherry pie.

I love everything about this pie. The crust and filling tastes homemade. I think these pies are made with sour cherries which give it that great taste.

This is the best commercial pie I've ever tasted! Lots of cherries, nice and tray, and the crust is just right. It's so big that I froze half of it to keep from pigging out, and a slice that was covered in the fridge was still perfect after 2 weeks.Yum!

Loved Sam's cherry pie. It had the right amount of sweetness that combine welled with the tartness of the cherries. If you like your cherry pie with a bit of tartness, this pie is for you.

There was a point when we were buying these every week while they had them in. Perfect combination of tart with delicious flaky across the holes up for 4 days. Highly recommend.

These Sam's club cherry pies are better than other 'store bought' pies. They are not sickeningly sweet like those pies. However, the crust on the one I bought was not soft and flaky. It was even hard and inedible in one spot. But the pie as a whole was very good.

I always loved Sam’s Club Cherry Pies until we bought this one. It was a great disappointment. A thin layer of rubber like cherry goop with about 10 or 12 distinguishable cherries in the whole pie and a few spots were sugared like old homemade jelly. No one went back for another piece. That was for sure.

I was disappointed, there were very few cherry’s. This was mainly sweet syrup sauce. I wi not buy it again