I have an eight pound 18 year old toy poodle missing most teeth, mostly blind and deaf who was getting thinner by the day. He eats every drop of this and enjoys it immensely. I originally bought it in club to try because of the ingredient list and the <$20 price on the shelf. He eats one full box per day. I was feeding Pedigree which I still do mix with the bigger dogs’ meals. His stool has gone from a few hard little rocklike pieces to a much more normal amount, texture, and well formed stool. He has filled back out. I will continue to buy it for the little one if/when it’s available despite the unfortunate substantial price increase. At 18 he should have what he enjoys.

My dogs Love the ingredients, easy to open boxes, love how easy it is to mix with the dogs dry food

My dog loves this! And I’m very glad that it’s not chicken since a lot of dogs are allergic to chicken, including him. I hope Sam’s Club keeps this product coming.

This dog food is working wonders for our dogs digestive health. He is a mature dog who has struggled with diarrhea and foul odor but this food has corrected these issues. He now has a consistent normal firm stool. In addition, he has an obvious personality improvement and, in turn, so do we. 😁

member's Mark turkey stew for dogs is a good product but my club doesn't want to carry it anymore! My dogs love it; I use it as a topper over their dry food. This seems to happen with a lot of Member's Mark items that I like!

My pup loves these! At first I was skeptical about the cartons, but the design of the box top is a breeze to cut open. Refold corners to seal and store in refrigerator for the next day. The consistency is not soupy but soft enough to stir into dry food.

The food is nothing like the photo, it's like a thick gravy. I should have looked at the ingredients - it's 82% moisture! So you're paying for MOISTURE - not meat and vegetables. I make homemade dog food and bought this as a back up, what a huge disappointment. My dogs eat it, but it's mostly MOISTURE, I would imagine it doesn't fill them up for long.

My dog would not eat it, I was hoping he would like it. He is a senior dog and can no longer eat kibble. He has to have soft foods:( Now we have a full box minus 2

The consistency is quite unpleasant. It's really, really unpleasant. It's gross to spoon out of the box. Neither of my dogs were overjoyed with it. I thought I'd give it a try because the cartons would mean less waste and I thought an easier dinnertime - but this stuff is like super thick gravy. I cannot express how gross it was.

Thankfully my dogs refused to eat it, it was liquid slop and kinda disgusting. I returned it!