They crumble in the bag, when i opened the bag at home there were almost no full pieces left. I have big dogs, I want to give them a single bite size piece not spoon feed them treat crumbs.

My dog is obsessed. These are her favorite treats. I love that there’s not a ton of additives and they’re made in the USA. They smell good, like actual meat. They’re soft, which is what the Queen of the house (she thinks she is anyways) prefers.

These are a huge hit with our pups as well as some of them that we dog sit. Good for dogs of all sizes. They're soft so my little toothless guy can eat them too.

Unfortunately these did not sit well with my pup, it gave him diarrhea and I had to return it. Not sure if it was the product itself or if he’s allergic to beef. I went back to the chicken jerky and everything was fine after that.

Was looking for something special for the pups for Christmas. They absolutely love these and one of them is quite picky. Not garbage like so many other treats and the price is very reasonable.

My dog loves these! A little too much! 😄 Wish they were a little less pricey but they’re still a better deal at Sam’s than anywhere else! Much better than a lot of other treats out there when looking at quality of ingredients.

I wish Sam’s would sell the beef strips in their stores again instead of just chicken strips. Some dogs are allergic to the chicken. I feel comfortable giving it to my K-9 son which he loves.

Our dog is a finicky eater and she loves these treats. She is now 16 years old and will only eat one other treat besides these. I love that they are soft for her and easy to put a few in my purse and carry with me when we are out and about.

Mostly crumbles and crumbs. We tried it hoping it would be a good option for Milo's Kitchen treats when we can't get them. The answer to that is "no".

BEST beef treat on the market and such a value at Sam’s! Our little guy has been on them for 3 years and Loves them. We like that they are soft and can be broken into smaller pieces when needed for rewards🤗