Something’s changed because these used to stay more solid but lately either they’re being poorly handled and shipped or the recipe has changed but by the time you get to the middle of the bag, so many have already crumbled and fallen apart. I might have to stop buying these.

Our picky dog loves these treats. He doesn't like them handed to him, he likes to search for them around the kitchen and living room. Each night after he eats, I'll scatter some of these around and he loves going sniffing them out and searching for them. He would eat the whole bag at one time if I'd let him.

It's soft and flavorful. My toothless senior dog takes her Meds easily since I disguise it in the Nudges. you hear her making a “num-num” sound as she eats it. My picky eater chihuahua cleans her plate with nudges sprinkled on it. My 85-pound mix breed dog goes nuts when it's treat time. He loves Nudges. He will do just about anything for it. It's a great training treat for him.

My pup was injured and out of state family sent a care pack with a small bag of these. He loved them and they were great so I bought this bag. The pieces are smaller and seem to be different than the other bag but the label is the same. Pup likes them but it wasn’t wat I was expecting.

My dogs love the Nudges. What I don’t like is that they come in crumbs and not as pictured. I believe the employees are just throwing these bags around and breaking the Nudges. I would love to get a normal bag when u order and not crumbs and yes I order 4 bags at a time .

While my dog loves these, I have had to throw away several bags due to their being dried out and/or being so crumbly that no longer bite size treats. In fairness, I was given a coupon for a replacement bag but since I have had this happen several times, I will no longer purchase. The other issue is cost. At nearly $30 a bag, these are more expensive than purchasing a small beef roast and dehydrating my own treats and without the preservatives or other issues I have experienced. If you choose to continue purchasing, please inspect the bag and make sure the contents are reddish brown and not faded brown as well as intact and not in crumbled pieces. I am also suspicious of what chemicals might be included and not listed in ingredients.

My German Shepherd likes them

My fur baby loves these. They do crumble/dry out easy if you don't keep package closed tight

very very picky Chihuahua loved them, and they seem very additive free.

Smelled bad. My dog did not like. Very crumbly. Ended up throwing them away.