We're sorry to see that, Aidan. We do appreciate your honest feedback & we will share your experience with our team. If you'd like to share more details with us, please feel free to reach out directly via https://bluebuffalo.com/about/contact/. Thank you.

Hi Jill, Thanks so much for the wonderful comments and for sharing your fur babies with us!

Hi Daniel, We really appreciate you taking the time to write these comments and we're thrilled that your furry family loves their treats!

We're so glad to hear it! Thanks for being a part of the Nudges family.