I have been buying these for a month now and my dogs only want these snacks and no others! They love them! and Im happy its only one ingredient, liver and no preservatives or bad stuff. I feel good feeding these to my 7 dogs. I just hope Sam's Club carries these as a permanent item and not discontinue it.

My cats and stry cats won't eat it at all!! Did I buy a bad one?? Maybe I should go buy a coffee grinder & try to grind them up and sprinkle over their food?? I tried to break them into small pieces, but some were so hard to break down. I even tried with water like it said in the feeding direction, but nope, I left it out to see if others would eat it, but only a few pieces were gone.

I have bought at least 5 bags on these, they are very healthy for the dogs. Now, I only buy freeze dry treats for my dogs. I bought some chicken, salmon, and other kinds from different places, but I would like to see Sam's start carry more freeze dry treats.

My dog absolutely loves these. It was the only treat she would eat when training her as a puppy so we have gone through quite a few bags. The price is great for the size of the bag and you get decent size pieces. The larger pieces are great for kongs because it takes a while for her to get it out. Keep these in stock!

Both my doggies love these treats. I love that they aren’t full of ingredients I can’t pronounce.

It’s a great treat since there is nothing but freeze dried liver.

Great Value. We add a few to our dogs food. One of them picks them out first. Both dog love them.

My dogs love these snacks

My four dogs and three cats love these bits of Liver.

My dog loves these! I hope they will keep these in stock permanently!!