The last couple of times I purchased Stewart's extremely overpriced liver treats, the containers were full of dust and crumbs. I worried that these might be the same, being that they are in a bag, but they hold up extremely well. They're fairly consistent in size and have minimal breakage or dust, which I just use to sprinkle on the dog's food. I really hope Sam's doesn't quit selling these.

My dog absolutely loves these. It was the only treat she would eat when training her as a puppy so we have gone through quite a few bags. The price is great for the size of the bag and you get decent size pieces. The larger pieces are great for kongs because it takes a while for her to get it out. Keep these in stock!

I like these because it is ONE ingredient and better for my dog than milk bone type treats. I came to order them again, but, they are out of stock!!! Please get these in asap! My dog just ran out of these!!! I would definitely recommend these for your dog or cat..

Good healthy snacks, dogs love them . Made in Canada.

Minimum ingredient my dogs love these !

Our dog and grand doggies loved the freeze dried beef liver!

My little ones don’t like them at all.

Wasn’t sure dogs would like this as they typically don’t like beef, but they really enjoy it

My dog won’t eat any other treats now

Use as a small treat, dog loves them.