Thank you for sharing this with us and giving it a try. It's great to hear that your cats eat our treats. We're sorry to hear that Friskies Party Mix Party Variety Pack, Cat Treats, wasn't a big hit for them. Sometimes, when there is a change to their food, cats may be reluctant to eat some or all of the new product. We'd recommend that consumers introduce a new food over a period of 7–10 days. The quality of our products and satisfactory experience of our consumers and their cats is our number one priority. We want to learn more about their preferences and offer our help. Please feel free to reach out to us here: www.purina.com/contact-us - The Friskies Team