These treats were broken into tiny pieces, as if the package had been tossed around for fun. Also the color of the treats was nearly gray, suggesting that they have been sitting in inventory for an extended period of time.

I have 2 dogs, a border collie and an Australian shepherd. They love pup-peroni! I always unless I run out and can't get to Sam's Club get them from Sam's Club because of the large bag. It lasts a long time.

When we had three dogs - we are now down to two - this was one of the few treats they all liked and would all eat. They are good value and the dogs enjoy them!

My dog loves these so much we had to start breaking them into small pieces. He gets a piece every time he goes out and does his thing. He would go out constantly just to get a piece, so we had to make the pieces smaller. Dogs aren't dumb.

Our Jack a poo loves these pupperoni’s. We break them up and when he does good he gets one. He goes right over to the table where his treats are and the pupperonis are his favorite.

One of my pups favorite treats….AND the treat that I hide medicines in. It is soft enough to make a small hole down the center and slip a pill into. No more fighting to medicate the fur babies.

Our pups love these! We have small dogs so we cut them in fourths and use them as every day treats. They won't go to bed without a bed time snack. Our dogs have us well trained.

Our dogs LOVE these treats! I love that they have some softness for my senior pug too. We go through a giant bag every month. They are easy to break in half or more pieces, which is nice when you have to smaller dogs. You get a lot of sticks in one bag too!

Good price

My girl loves them