[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Received Pipe to I Original Beef Flavor for testing and reviewing purposes. My Jazzy loved them. I gave her once and she came right back for another after she finished that one. I will be buying her these now since she really enjoys them. I highly recommend.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This is my dog's favorite treat. I changed about a year ago due to her getting older and the vet recommending harder treats for her teeth. But these are still her favorites. She will do anything for these treats.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dogs love any of the Pup-Peroni treats. They’re a great motivator when practicing commands. Apparently we need more because our larger dog stole the bag off the counter and shared with her sister!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog loves these! And I'm so glad that red 40 isn't in them. The bag is 5.6 oz. And it's a pretty big bag for treats. I usually break them in thirds because she has a tendency to eat a lot! The texture is like a slim Jim and they snap easily. They smell like slim Jim's too. They make her happy when I open the bag.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dog just fell in love with these when I opened them. He loved the smell and waited, well impatiently to have one. As soon as he hears the package he will sit and try to be his cute self begging for one. I love that these are so good to him and he loves the taste and smell so much. We will definitely be getting him more of these especially for his Christmas gift this year.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My dogs absolutely love these treats! They’ve become their new favorite, and incorporating them into our training routine has been so easy. The size is perfect for rewarding them, and they get so excited every time they see the treats.

My dog will do anything for Pup-peroni! She loves them. I thought once that she would make a great commercial if anyone could capture how fast she runs to her crate at night when she sees me get a stick of Pup-peroni! She is a very picky eater and i just wish there was a dog food that tastes like Pup-peroni!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My babies LOVE Pup-Peroni treats, the only ones they will eat. The look forward to them everyday! They are a good texture and are chewy and soft. My babies won’t eat a crunchy treat anymore after eating these.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] What a great smelling easy to share product. They loved them! Can’t recommend the product highly enough! If there was one improvement it would be to make a larger package. Maybe that would make it easier to buy.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] These are very much loved by the dogs we have here. There are two larger ones and a small dog. I break up the treats into smaller bites for the small Pomeranian because otherwise she won't eat anything like treats. These are easily breakable, and yet do not fall apart easily either. The bigger dogs eat them in either half the size they are or the whole stick. They love them too. They don't refuse them. Dogs will eat anything almost but there is something special about giving them these, they were made especially for dogs. The beef aroma is very much noticeable but not too overpowering though either. They don't give the dogs bad breathe. These are handy to have when I want to spoil or train them. Two of the dogs have some training issues still and these treats help.