Okay, This used to be my favorite but something has changed! I hate it now! What is going on? I thought it was me so I looked it up and MANY people are having the same problem! I'm going to my second favorite until you fix this! Cold stone creamery (sweet cream)

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My whole family has been buying your creamer for years but this one did not make it twice does not pass the flavor test in our house so will not be buying it again we will be buying the original creamer

Over a decade ago, the girl who would eventually become my wife and I found coffee mate's Italian sweet cream creamer together and it became the absolute staple for every coffee drink we would continue to have throughout the ensuing years. Every morning it would go in my brewed coffee thermos for work or anytime we wanted a relaxing summer weekend with an Irish coffee, it would go in with the classic drink mixture. A few months ago (now in 2023) I bought the large bottle and thought that it tasted sour, as if it had gone bad. I threw it away and bought another one and it also tasted disgusting. My wife tried it and said, "wow, yeah, there is something wrong with this! Maybe there was a large local shipment that went bad?" I reached out to coffee mate and they were at least honest enough to let me know that they had changed the formula and stated that they were sorry I didn't care for it anymore. They were gracious enough to send me some free coupons for creamer, but unfortunately all that means is that I could now go obtain more of the creamer my wife and I no longer enjoyed for free or we could get one of their other flavors (which by no stretch could even remotely equal what the Italian sweet cream used to taste like for the majority of our lives) and our long-term "coffee memories" together. I have attempted to find a substitute among several other brands, but have not found one I enjoy. An enormous part of our morning and evening life is gone. Every once in a blue moon, I'll reluctantly pick up a smaller bottle of the "new" Italian creamer, but only if I have enough cocoa powder to mask the new heavily diminished flavor as much as possible. The old formula was 5 stars and beyond, but the new one is 1 or 2 at the very best. Please please bring back the classic flavor, or (if you must) produce them both and market the new one with a different title so those who loved the original formula can differentiate it and happily buy ilthe classic formula again long into the future!

Been buying this for a year now. When I first tasted it I loved it...silky smooth exactly like I expected sweet Italian cream to taste like. The past couple weeks it's not tasted right. I have bought 3 bottles that all taste like a flavor has Been added that isn't supposed to be there. I couldn't quite pin the Taste that I'm tasting but it seems off. Its kinda of cinnamony or oat milky like. It almost tastes like the liquor rumchata which could be why I noticed it was off tasting. I hate Rumchata.

I have been drinking this for close to 10 years now it is the only creamer I like but something has changed in the flavor. It almost tastes like a caramel type now. 5 star product on the previous formula but now it's like any other caramel flavored one. It even smells of caramel or vanilla now. 64 oz bottle bought this week.

Why is there artificial sweetener ie: sucralose in the regular version of the Italian sweet cream creamer? The artificial sweetener should only be in the zero sugar version only so customers can choose sugar free if they want the artificial sweeteners and regular version if they can't have them. Why is it in both?

Purchased several bottles with the new label and they are disgusting. I've been using this creamer for a decade and even stuck with it after the sour-taste debacle of 2020. But this is not good and I would rather pay for Starbucks than use this creamer anymore.

Sugar free Italian sweet creme has been my favorite flavor since it came out. Last week I bought 3 more bottles with the new cap. The coffee mate is flavorless. I went to a different store and bought 3 bottles with the old cap. It's still flavorless and has zero sweetness. I have 6 bottles that taste awful. What has happened?

I had bought 3 bottles of your Italian Sweet Cream since it's been my favorite. You can say nothing was changed, but all 3 bottles went down the drain! Bad flavor and even a wrong smell. Too bad-- I'm looking for a different brand now. Don't buy June 10, 2021 exp date Italian Sweet Cream. Thanks for your time

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] TRIED THIS TYPE, DID NOT LIKE, WILL STICK WITH REGULAR VANILLA THAT WE HAVE USED FOR DECADES. WISH WE HAD KEPT THE RECEIPT FOR REFUND. WE WILL KEEP USING OTHER COFFEE-MATE FLAVORS. PLEASE SEND REPLACEMENT COUPON IF YOU COULD.