My dogs love the treats with pumpkin, coconut oil, and peanut butter. But they don’t really like these. Occasionally they will take one, but reluctantly.

My dogs hate these. They loved the Members Mark Peanut butter grain free crunchy bones you use to carry. Bring them back please. I been ordering them from your site.

My pups really like the flavor of these treats. I wish 90% of the bones weren’t just broken pieces and were whole bones. If sold in-store, this might not be the case.

I got the peanut butter ones since MM was out of stock. My dog will not eat them & they smell like the oil, no peanut butter at all. Will wait till Member's Mark peanut butter dog bone come bk in stock. Do not buy this brand.

Bought a box of each flavor and none of my 4 German Shepherds would touch them. Ended up throwing them out. I’m having a very hard time finding treats for my dogs at Sam’s. They loved the Irish Rover jerky discs, but they’ve been out of stock for months. Tried the Irish Rover Pork and Apple Sausage treats and dogs wouldn’t touch it. Treats had a thick waxy exterior and no smell. Threw them out. Recently tried the Member’s Mark version of the beef jerky and came very dry, pale in color and little smell. Gave a small piece to my jerky- obsessed shepherd and he left it in his crate. Will be returning those. Dogs only eating the grain free Member’s Mark treats. Please bring back the Irish Rover jerky.

Our dogs love these. They're easy to break into smaller pieces too.

My dogs LOVE these treats.

My finicky dogs enjoy these. They’re are quite a few broken ones due to the texture. I didn’t mind as they only get a half one.

Our dog does not like these. He picks them out of his food bowl or ignores the food all together if it is in there. Waste of money.

Changed the recipe for the worse. Crumbles, less healthy ingredients, Nasty gray color. They used to smell like peanut butter, but no longer.