You replaced the Members Mark peanut butter treats with these disgusting grey treats that my dogs absolutely hate. They smell and look awful. My dogs just leave them on the floor and walk away. Returned.

I got these delivered and my dog loves them, they are healthy only 4 ingredients. And they smell pretty good. Packaging came undamaged. 10/10 would recommend.

My dog is allergic to a lot of ingredients in common treats but he can have these and loves them! He can't get enough because they are so delicious!

We had purchased this given the all natural ingredients. These treats are great and smell really good.

My dogs Ronni and WallE love these healthy treats!

These treats are great! They smell just like French Toast :D My Golden Retriever loves them!

very happy that they are only a few ingredients and smell good