Here's the math: Charmin Members Mark 32 Rolls/ 45 rolls/ PACKAGE PACKAGE $22.98 $19.98 .................. .................... .......................................... 6,976 10,575 Sheets/PACKAGE .003294 .00189 Cost/SHEET $34.84 $19.98 Cost for 10,575 Sheets $14.86 Savings $16.03 Savings, including Sales Tax And the quality? Right up there with Charmin. Charmin might have a slight edge based on who you ask but the $16 in savings turns the tide.

Oy! Terrible stuff. I've never in my life seen such linty toilet paper. Also, many rolls were very rough...not soft at all. So I'm confused by the name...'Ultra Soft Premium'....not at all. Maybe it was a fluke. But it was SO bad I'd never buy again. Maybe your money would be better spent on a different TP. :(

I bought this toilet paper about a month ago to try out since we can return it if we're not happy with it. So far it's been really good. To us it feels a lot like Charmin. It's strong, too. Haven't had any incidents of the paper ripping or shredding. Would definitely buy, again.

Cleans your booty good

This brand is the best

This is absolutely the best toilet paper. I have tried many different types & this is hands down the softest, most absorbent, and strong. The price is great, too! I just wish it would stay in stock, but it's not a secret so it's popular with many people.

As far as the tissue is concerned, it gets an A++ ... very good quality and reliable. As far as Sam's Club is concerned, they get an F++. I could understand, once the 'panic' came, them not having it in stock, but now that that panic and chaos has worn off, it is STILL not back in stock! I wonder, sometimes, if Sam's has just stopped making it and is hoarding what they have. I wonder, btw, if they haven't done the same on the paper towels. Makes no sense not to have these items back in stock after this long.

We used to always have buy Name Brand TP. My husband is super picky I bought a case of this, when the name brand price became ridiculous. He actually thinks it’s softer and really likes it. We been getting it about 3 years. I preferred the Mega-rolls but these are just as good also.

At the risk of being overly graphic, this paper clings after wiping; you cannot get clean. You will sit down the next time and you will smell it. It is grotesque. Going back to quilted Northern which we've used for years with none of these problems. To Sam's Club's credit, they took the remaining rolls in return.

After Cottonelle went byebye, tried this & found comparable to Charmin. Pretty good. Just wish Sam’s Club would make a store brand toilet paper that is 1-ply!! Just noticed price went up another $1 this month :( That kinda sucks. But will still buy! …And sam’s club knows that :(