These Collagen sticks have been a big win at our house. Our dogs love them. We don't do rawhide. These sticks are soft enough that I can cut them in half for my dogs. I have to use a utility blade plier cutter, but they can be cut. Once the bag is open, the chews will get harder over time. I have learned to cut the entire bag after opening. The longer it is open, the harder cutting the chews will be. It is true they will not last as long as rawhide, hey are Collagen and you should not expect them to. If you truly need something that lasts a long time, a bully stick is probably a better choice.

I bought these about a month ago for my 4-legged furry kids and they love them, absolutely love them. You won't be disappointed in the length or thickness, easy for my two dogs of average size, a Beagle and a Mutt about the size of a Cocker Spaniel to enjoy without any issues with them. I think the price is fair for the quality and quantity you get.

Dogs love them but they are more like treats and not chews. Gone by the time I turned back around to see if they liked them. I won't buy them again. Too many calories for a treat and too expensive for what they are. I'll stick with real bully sticks and normal treats.

Had to take back to SAMS for refund. Gave my golden retriever the runs.

My dog loves these!!! Long lasting chewy fit the tough chewer

My three dogs live these!

My dog and my son's dog wouldn't eat them

My Lab chews them but won't eat them. They just make a mess.

Gritty. Lead warning on packages.

I thought these would last longer then they did. My Lab/Pit went thru one in a matter of minutes !! She does enjoy them. So I will buy more .