Duke loves these for his treat of the day! He leads me to the kitchen cabinet and sniffs around when I open the door. He gobbles these quickly. They are crunchy and a little messy so I put him in the crate for this treat.

Our big dogs love these, but owners not so much. They break up into very small pieces and we end up just cleaning up after they eat this treat. No fun. As far as the dogs go, it’s a tasty yummy treat for them. Great for heavy chewers, but messy.

Perfect for my pleasure chewer, doesn't last 5 minutes with my chewer that acts like it's his job. I bought these because the package stated they were good for "active chewers".

My dogs love them but not too substantial. A couple of good chomps and 5 mins later and my two med sized 50 lb pooches have made two ‘sticks’ disappear.

These are really nice for my pups teeth! I really see an improvement in the tarter not building up! Plus he’s learned to really chew his bone without any large chunks! Really excited the time it takes him to eat it and poop is not as mushy!

Just too big for my 30lb dog. Next day after chewing on it he had diarrhea-only thing different in diet. Threw giant bag in trash. Shouldn’t have bought to try from Sam’s.

Dog likes them, but the rolls crumble and there are shards everywhere. I can slice other types of rolls into smaller pieces to make them last but these crumble when you try

Our dog Marlin, a Goldendoodle, thoroughly enjoys these. They're more brittle than I thought they would be - I was thinking they'd last longer and be more chewy. Overall, I would buy them again. Just keep an eye on your pup when they have one.

5 ⭐️ collagen rolls. Everyone from my 13 pound puppy to my 90 pound princess Absolutely loves these rolls! They happily run to their kennels just to get one.

My dog liked the first one rhen he wasnt interested, then he decided they were goid and got really sick after eating these because he wasnt fully chewing them up. I woildnt buy again.