I tried a sample of one of the magic erasers and it was amazing, lasted me for over a week and I would have kept using it had my husband not thrown it out. I couldn't remember which one it was so I bought this one. All I did was bend it and it ripped. Any stuck on stain and little pieces start falling off. I don't get where the "extra power" comes in because it is really weak. I'm going to try the others hoping to find the first one I used but I won't buy this one again.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is the gift that keeps on giving. It never ceases to amaze me on how superb it cleans my bathroom tub and any extra dirty surface. I always finish my cleaning time feeling happy.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] My free PINCHme Mr. Clean Magic Eraser was used on my shoes. It was more durable, however it seems the more wet it is the easier it rips. It is still a good product because it does give my shoes a like new clean.

I can't believe this magic eraser is that bad now. Every time I start to use it , I don't even need to press too hard on it and it starts to break into tiny pieces that are falling off my hands. I have to quickly use wet toilet paper to remove them from my tub, before they clog it. It is such a steal of money from the brand because it is very expensive compared to the extremely low quality you're getting. I wish I could give them a zero star.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is truly an exceptional cleaning tool. With its innovative design and remarkable effectiveness, it effortlessly tackles stubborn stains and grime, leaving surfaces looking immaculate. I was pleasantly surprised by its versatility, as it worked wonders on various surfaces like walls, countertops, and appliances. The sponge-like texture combined with its powerful cleaning agents allowed me to effortlessly remove tough marks without any harsh chemicals. Furthermore, the Magic Eraser's durability impressed me; it held up well during extended use without crumbling or falling apart. I appreciate that it's odorless, making it suitable for sensitive individuals. Overall, the Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is a reliable and efficient cleaning solution that consistently delivers remarkable results. It has become an essential part of my cleaning routine, and I highly recommend it to anyone seeking a truly magical cleaning experience.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I used my MR. CLEAN MAGIC ERASER on several different places (walls, bathroom tile, etc.) and it was able to remove stains and marks with ease. MR. CLEAN still shows to be one of the best cleaning brands out there with quality products.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I received a Mr. Clean Extra Durable Magic Eraser from PINCHme to try and give my opinion on. I already used and loved Magic Eraser, but this Extra Durable one is even better. The one down side of the "regular" Magic Erasers is that you do tend to go through them pretty quick, especially when using them for hard jobs. This Extra Durable one, cuts down on that. Overall, I would buy Mr. Clean Magic Erasers again and would recommend them.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] As always me clean came through for me. My kids got crayon on the walls and the extra durable one got it off completely. This was all with just water. It did take off a little bit of paint but I think that may just be the type of paint my complex used.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I was given Mr. Clean Magic Eraser for free from PinchMe. I used it in the bathroom to clean the sink and it did a pretty good job getting a couple rusty stains off. I also used it on the baseboards and it worked wonders to get those clean. I don’t recommend using it on the walls as it will take the paint off!

These sponges completely fell apart every time I used one. I was wiping off a cabinet and the sponge broke in half with multiple particles dropping to the floor. They erase dirt well but not worth it when I have to use all 4 because they crumble like chalk. Then I have to vacuum the pieces up. For the “extra durable” moniker, I really expected a lot more.