These sponges completely fell apart every time I used one. I was wiping off a cabinet and the sponge broke in half with multiple particles dropping to the floor. They erase dirt well but not worth it when I have to use all 4 because they crumble like chalk. Then I have to vacuum the pieces up. For the “extra durable” moniker, I really expected a lot more.

I love this Durable Magic Eraser! It has cleaned so many tough stains with little to no pressure on my part. Helps this mom clean faster and more effective. I appreciate that they have separate erasers for different rooms and these durable can be used anywhere. Highly recommended!

I've been such a fan of the Magic Eraser since it first came out, my friends tease me about my gushing. That is not the case for "Extra Durable". Pick a different type unless you want it crumbling into the tub or bottom of the shower. I clean weekly for 2 people as well as have 4 kids, so i do know what they normally last for. I brought 2 ME thinking I could do 3 bathrooms for a friend w those. I am now done w a full tub/shower bathroom & a shower stall bathroom and ended up w mess of the ME crumbles at the bottom of each! Not to mention that it's left me hanging for the 3rd bathroom. Magic Eraser is a fantastic product---the Extra Durable is a false advertisement, though.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I always have mr clean erasers in my household. These are so durable and made well . They literally clean anything off of almost any surface. Marker of a wall, grease of the oven, etc. I mean I think everyone needs these in their house hold. Easy to use. Just get slightly wet and scrub the area. Easy peasy

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I've seen this Mr..Clean Magic Eraser around at the store but never got around to trying it and I kind of wish I did sooner! It's good for quick cleans when you have some stains around the house. Did a good job. The sponge is strong but after some use it did have signs of wear, piece broke of after some time. But it's a good size so I was able to use the other sides. Overall a good product for quick stain cleaning.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Sometimes paper towel or rags don't give enough oomph to get the job done when I'm tackling a mess like stove cleaning or hard water stains in my tub. Mr. Clean Magic Erasers give me that something extra I need to clean the bigger jobs without wasting a lot of paper towels in the process. These sponges have staying power and will last through a tough job without having to replace it part way through. It's a great value when you consider how many paper towels you save using just one of these sponges.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is exactly what the name implies! My nephew had a moment and used markers on my wall, I’m renting so my soul instantly left my body . I ended up getting a magic eraser and was relieved to see the marks erase like it was nothing! Definitely recommend to any parents

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This Mr. Clean Magic Eraser is the best version yet. Prior to it being made more durable I really didn’t enjoy using the product because though it was affective the lifespan was cut short. Now that the issue has been resolved it is my go to cleaning product.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] The Mr. Clean Magic Eraser does just what its name says- works magically! I used it on tough toilet bowl rings and they disappeared! I've literally tried everything to get my toilet sparkling white. But this did the trick!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] this sponge works great, once you damp it with water, it works good, especially for your bathroom and walls. you can use mr clean magic eraser in the toilet bowls too, it works great for the kitchen stoves too. I use it for everything it can be used for.