The first time I bought these, they were soft. The last time I purchased them, maybe around the end of the year, one bag was really hard. My dogs either chew on them long enough for the pill to pop out, or swallow the thing whole. The price is better than Greenies, but if they're changing to this harder consistency I won't be buying them anymore.

Horrible. These pill pockets are hard. My dog actually spits out his pill because these are so hard that he has to really chew them. With the Greenies pill pockets, he had no problem because they were soft and pliable and my dog didn’t have to chew very hard. These are especially horrible for senior dogs with less teeth….

These work very well for us - I have to give my dog two pills each morning and I am able to take one of these and split it in two. She loves the pill pockets and takes her pill. I've never had a problem with them being stale. My dog is not a picky eater, but she would never take a pill without it being hidden in something.

Easy way to get your pet to swallow pills

My dogs really like these!

My dogs will not eat them. They are dry and hard. Difficult to get the pill/capsule in. Don't waste your money.

These pill pockets are terrible! Wasted money and you can barely get a pill in them! Hard as a rock! Save your money and bring the greenies back

Terrible! Hard & oddly shaped, not soft & flexible like greenies. Tired of Sam's club changing their products to these cheap generic alternatives.

These are not the same quality or texture of a pill pocket. They are too hard to wrap around a pill. My lab (a lab!!!!) refused to eat them at times because it didn't hide the pill well enough.

I like the bigger size of these (compared to Greenies), but they are hard, like they are stale, and do not shape around pills. I found that they become softer and easier to use if placed in the microwave for 7 seconds.