Occasionally, some of the containers have potato chunks that are hard and less flavorful. Most of the time the potatoes in the soup are soft and well-distributed in the liquid. When the potatoes are soft, the soup is very very good.

I buy this all the time. Family loves. This last time, ordered from Pickup. One container was open an spilling out. The other container had BROCCOLI soup in it. How did this happen? So disappointing.

We loved this soup, but it’s been months that our local Sam’s club haven’t had them in stock. We’d greatly appreciate it if you can restock these! Best potato soup we’d ever had!

A step below Panera. Has that watery aftertaste. Ideal for 2 people only. Hardly any chunk to the potatoes. Flavor was fine. I would not buy this again & crap I still have one more in the freezer.

I opened the soup which was sealed and it contained a PINK film and who know what type of bacteria in the soup. The worst part is this is the second time this has occurred when buying soup from Sam’s

I used to buy this soup because it was really good but the last few times the potatoes were very hard although there was plenty of them.Very little bacon now as well .Will not be buying again anytime soon.

We love Potato Soup but did not like the taste and consistency of this soup at all. Not at all what we expected especially from Sams. Can’t understand the reviews unless there is no consistency with the various batches that are made.

I used to love this soup. My last purchase was my last very weird chunks of stuff in the soup and no it wasn't potatoes it looked like a dead rodent. Made me want to vomit and immediately threw it all out.

Be very careful with any of these "plastic" soup containers. Mine broke, I salvaged most of the soup. But it had shards of the broken plastic in it that were like glass. Threw it out to prevent a trip to the hospital or worse.

An attempt, but it falls a bit short. Good, not very good or great. Potatoes are under cooks as well as onions. I get it...reheat, but still falls short.