I dont know what is wrong with you all that gave this poor reviews but this is amazing. My 6 year old refilled his bowl four times. FOUR TIMES. And he doesnt really eat real food. I thought it was quite possibly the best potato soup i have ever eaten. I loved it and will now buy it all winter.

Guys, this soup is completely horrible! It doesn't taste like any potato soup I've ever had. It has potatoes, or something that looks like potatoes, but it doesn't taste like potatoes. All these 5 star reviews must be fake. It's awful. I made myself eat most of one container, because I'm a cheapskate, but couldn't make myself eat the other one. Should've taken it back and gotten a refund.

This was my go to soup to get at Sams, but it went out of stock for a while and when it came back we tried it and something wasn't the same. The potatoes were underdone or hardly done at all, the flavor just wasn't quite as good. I dont know what happened, but it was the best potato soup I'd had and its definitely changed (OR we were incredibly unlucky and got a bad batch of it). If it goes back to how it was originally, then oh yeah I'll sing it's praises again.

I love all of the Member's Mark soups, but the potato is definitely my favorite. The soup is rich and creamy. It's quick to heat up in the microwave. Add a little shredded cheese and bacon bits for extra flavor. The price is quite reasonable, and a good bit less than other refrigerated soups. The soups also freeze well in the original container. The only downside is you do have to watch the expiration dates. Occasionally an old package will find it's way into the store display. But, the dates are very clearly displayed in large print on the cardboard holder, so it is easy to check the date quickly. I try to avoid buying these using curbside because of the dates.

This is absolutely the worst soup I’ve ever had. Only SOME of the potatoes are actually tender. The broth looks and smells like upchuck and many of the potato pieces have brown rotten spots in them. Unfortunately, I bought 2 two packs based on previous ratings and comments. I won’t make that mistake again!!

I tried this soup for the first time today. I heated in the microwave, sprinkled some graded cheese on top and I had some left over bacon from breakfast so I crumbled some bacon on top and sprinkled some dried chives and WoW I have what taste like a fantastic home made soup! I will be buying more!

I have had this soup many times over the years. never had a bad batch. It's always full of veggies. However, this latest batch is very peppery. but still delicious 😋. I added some shredded cheddar on top and it toned down the black pepper taste.

Freezes great for have one now, one later

Was great flavor , but potatoes were not done enough

Good flavor and makes a great add-on to dinner.