Skip to Main Content
Sam's Club
Sam's Club
All Departments
All Services
Customer reviews for Member's Mark Hotel Premier 14" Hybrid Mattress (Available in Medium, Plush, and Firm) for
Member's Mark Hotel Premier 14" Hybrid Mattress (Available in Medium, Plush, and Firm)
4.1 out of 5 stars
stars
291 ratings194 reviews
  1. 5 stars66% (191)
  2. 4 stars11% (31)
  3. 3 stars7% (21)
  4. 2 stars4% (13)
  5. 1 star12% (35)

Member photos

  • +115 images
Sort by |
Showing 111-120 of 194 reviews
Jan 24, 2026
Joe
1 out of 5 stars review

DO NOT BUY THIS MATTRESS! Worst quality control!

DO NOT BUY THIS MATTRESS! DO NOT BUY THIS MATTRESS! DO NOT BUY THIS MATTRESS! If the above warning doesn't convince you, I'll explain why. I bought this mattress to replace a Sealy I bought at Sam's over 11 years ago. The advertised features seemed convincing, and I liked the idea of it being a hybrid mattress because I'm not completely sold on all foam construction. I was also skeptical of a king size mattress being compressed into a relatively small box, but I reluctantly decided to buy it anyway. This ended up being one of the worst decisions I've made in my life. After bringing the mattress home and opening the box to allow it to expand, I was shocked to see that the mattress is folded and rolled under compression. I was thinking there's no way that the coils could not be compromised with this packing method, and I would soon realize that my assumption would be correct. 1. The first thing I noticed was the awful smell coming from the mattress, resembling something like mildew. The literature that came with the mattress noted that there would be a smell and that it would subside with time. This may be true, but it's not a good user experience for something that's claimed to be a premium product. 2. The next thing I noticed was the mattress not being squared (not 90 degrees at every corner). Some of the sides were even curved and would look bad if I had put bedding on it. 3. The foam top beneath the removable cover was not applied evenly with the other mattress layers. You can see in the attached pictures how the foam top has an overhang on one side of the bed. 4. The mattress looked wavy coming out of the box, but I gave adequate time to ensure it was not a problem with the expansion process. Sure enough, the waves never went away after 17 days without sleeping on the mattress. This is the number of days that passed before the attached pictures were taken. 5. The mattress is not true to size as other commenters have mentioned. It was at least 3" too short in some areas, less in others because of the cruved edges. 6. The worst part of all this is the lack of customer support from Sam's. I would not be able to return the mattress the same way I bought it from the store because it came compressed in the box, and I was told that I would have to return it to the store. This is now a huge inconvenience because I don't have a vehicle large enough to transport the mattress in its expanded state. I'll like have to rent a moving truck to finally be done with this poor excuse of a mattress being marketed as a premium product. I have enjoyed being a Sam's Club member, but this experience really has me thinking I should drop my membership and join their competitor that opened a location across the street. I am appalled by the lack of quality control on this mattress. There's no way that the manufacturer is held to any standard, and the worst part is that it's made in the USA, which is supposed to offer the best quality money can buy.

  • +1 image
Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
May 9, 2025
May
1 out of 5 stars review

Poorly assembled

Hotel premier hybrid firm mattress. I purchased this mattress about 5 months ago and immediately noticed it was crooked the foam and coils didn't line up on some of the edges which resulted in one side of the mattress having no coils under the foam and caused it to gave way as soon as you sat on the edge. Husband already fell off the bed twice because of this, but the only reason we kept this long is because it took us so long to look for a mattress in the first place, we live 24 miles away from the store, and retuning it required us finding time and a vehicle big enough to transport back to the store. When you lie on the bed where all layers line up it is actually very comfortable which is why we found this so dissapointing going through the hassle of returning it and looking for a different mattress which we are still in the process of. If i could be garanteed this wouldn't happen again I would probably get it again since it was comfortable, but buying it and having to return it again if it comes out poorly assembled again is just not something I want to deal with.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
reply from Performance Sleep Products

Hi May, thank you for taking the time to share your experience with us. I&#39;m truly sorry to hear about the issues you&#39;ve encountered with your mattress. It’s clear that the misalignment of the foam and coils has caused significant inconvenience and frustration, and I completely understand how disappointing this must be—especially after the effort you put into selecting a mattress and the challenges involved in returning it.<br /><br />We appreciate your honest feedback, and I want to assure you that this is not the standard we strive for. Your comfort and safety are extremely important to us, and we take quality concerns like this very seriously.<br /><br />To help resolve this, I’d like to offer the following options:<br /><br />Return Assistance: If you prefer to return the mattress, you can contact customer service at the Club and help you with a return. <br />New Mattress: We are happy to send you a new mattress to replace this one.<br /><br />Please let us know which option works best for you, or if there’s anything else we can do to make this right. Your comfort and satisfaction are our top priorities, and we’d love the opportunity to restore your trust in our products.

Feb 4, 2026
Jamielee
1 out of 5 stars review

Terrible quality

I've been trying to buy a mattress for 3 years. I've bought memory foam and I hate it due to it making my hips hurt and I sink so far down into the bed I have to climb out. I thought this would be a good choice as it's hybrid. No. I got it in a box all rolled up. Opened it and let it expand. I bought the ultra plush thinking it would be perfect. It has a zip cover on it and there was tons of slack like it was missing 1/4 of the mattress. The springs were sticking out really bad. I slept on it two nights and it caused horrendous back pain. I happened to have another 3inch memory foam mattress from a camper van I sold. I forced that mattress into the zip cover and I have salvaged it. No way was I going to try to return this as I would have probably had to haul it over an hour to my nearest Sam's Club. But it was NOT worth the over 400$ I spent on it. I do not recommend.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
Mar 14, 2026
MICHAEL
3 out of 5 stars review

Plush is Soft. Maybe Medium is Better

Purchased King Plush Style. Wife is 130lbs and I am 200lbs. She is doing Well. I am feeling Sunk in already. Heavy Mattress. Overall Rate it a C. My hips when im on my back and side go in to far leaving my lower backside uncomfortable. I am 6ft tall so I'm not like im a huge guy. Unsure of this purchase. Maybe Medium would have been better.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
May 27, 2025
Becker
5 out of 5 stars review

LOVE Our New Mattresses!

We bought two twins a couple weeks ago (firm for husband and medium for me) for our king size platform. I really couldn't be happier, and my husband likes his, too. We both slept better immediately. Less tossing and turning from him, and I wake up in the same position I fall asleep in, with no extra stiffness/soreness. My only complaint is that when we measured (twice!), the twin x 2 was the correct size according to the chart, but now that they are here, unwrapped, and inflated, maybe the twin XLs would have fit a little better length-wise? Not a big deal for us, though...the foot of the bed is covered in sheets/blankets anyway, so it's not worth time or effort to exchange over a couple inches...but this is just a heads up for others who have different taste in firmness levels and want to try doing the same. Wait for the occasional $50 off and splurge. I think these mattresses are definitely worth it!

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
reply from Member's Mark Team

Thank you so much for sharing your experience, Becker! We're thrilled that both you and your husband are sleeping better and enjoying your customized firmness levels—that's exactly what we hope for with our mattresses. It's great to know the firm and medium combo is working so well for you both. We also really appreciate your note about sizing. While two standard twins do match the width of a king, you're right that Twin XLs are typically a better fit lengthwise for most king platforms. Your feedback is super helpful for others considering the same setup.

Dec 16, 2025
GLC
3 out of 5 stars review

A bit too soft for a Medium. Just a heads up!

Wife and I bought the Medium version of this in store. This mattress feels like a plush and you sink in pretty deep while sitting. It is comfy while laying but a little to soft for us. We ended up ordering the Firm version online the next day. Will be returingin the Medium version once the other comes. Hopefully the Firm will serve us better.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
Feb 1, 2026
Philip
5 out of 5 stars review

I love this bed! I was weary about buying a bed in a bag but decided to give it a whirl. I will never look back about buying a mattress from a bed store. I am pleasantly surprised with how easy and efficient it was to put up. I was able to sleep on it the same night, but it continued to firm up for the next 3 days or so. I bought the firm for my room while my husband bought the medium for his room. I had back surgery about 2 years ago and my old mattress was 11 years old. This is my first time buying a firm bed. Now, the firmness will be a perceived feeling, but it is like a hotel mattress. It conforms to the body but doesn’t sink in. It is perfect for me and supports my back and hips perfectly. The medium also feels supportive but it conforms a bit more to the body and has a bit more give in the mattress. I have no aches or pains on either bed but the firm is more supportive for me and better on my joints. My husband prefers the medium but likes the firm, too. It really is just a matter of preference. Overall, medium is a perfect bed but the firm is more supportive for my condition. I’m very pleased with my purchase

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
Dec 31, 2024
1fastmax
5 out of 5 stars review

Very Comfortable- Twin XL Firm

I purchased the Firm mattress and have had it about a month, and it has really made a difference in my sleep and helped greatly with my lower back pain. I would call it more of a medium firm, the memory foam top really adds to the comfort but there is a firm layer under that which adds great support. Sleeping on this mattress along with an adjustable base and I do not want to get out of the bed in the morning.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
Jun 4, 2025
Claudette1209
2 out of 5 stars review

Twin xl is really twin standard

This is the 2nd time I have ordered a members mark twin xl mattress from Sam’s. The first time it was the 12” and this time it’s the 14”. Both times I received a mattress that was twin size not twin xl, contrary to what the box was marked as. I returned the 12” and now I will be returning this 14”. You cannot use a twin size comfortably on an adjustable split king bed or frame. It’s awful having the pillows falling behind the top of mattress all night. This mattress also has very little foam thickness on the springs, it’s only 4” thick on a 14” thick mattress. The mattress doesn’t even expand larger than 13”. I have enclosed photos of this. It’s so bad that the mattress cover is huge compared to the mattress. I enclosed photos of the length measurements along the top of the mattress and along the bottom of the mattress. Customer service states that the length is +-1” well this is 74” on the top and 77” on the spring side. I have 3” of space between the headboard and mattress with the bed set to flat and you can see in the photos that’s with the spring side up which is the longer of the sides, so compared to my husband’s side which is a foam mattress it’s a big difference. I don’t know what the other sizes of this mattress are like but the twin xl is awful. The springs are felt as the night goes on which I say is because of the lack of foam. This 14” also has less coils then then the 12” according to the product information for both mattresses. Save your money folks, this is not the bargain it seems.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666
reply from Member's Mark Team

We are sorry to hear about your experience with our mattress, Claudette. This will be shared with our product team to make sure they take a look at the current design for improvements. A standard Twin – 39" x 75", and Twin XL – 39" x 80". (= or - 1") The 12" hybrid and the 14" hybrid are both different designs and not comparable. Please know that you are eligible for a full refund with the Member's Mark 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. You can contact the Member Support Team at (888) 301-0332 if you need assistance.

Aug 20, 2024
Sams customers
3 out of 5 stars review

Returning. Suffered lower back pain by 2nd night

When we set it up it felt like we were laying on something hard, so I unzipped the cover only to find that they had put the mattress in upside down, and we were laying on the coils. I hope that's not what they do for all mattresses. We flipped it over, and rezipped it, and initially it felt comfortable, but by 2nd & 3rd day my lower back was killing me. We will be returning this. I would not recommend to anyone that could suffer back pain.

Helpful?56MNVX2X80RL13890064666