I purchase two packs of the tilapia. And both packages either smelled of ammonia before cooking and smelled of ammonia after cooking. Both packages of fish will purchase in August 2024, and both were bad! I have always enjoyed the fish that I purchased from Sam's club but this purchase have totally changed that. I will no longer be buying frozen fish from Sam's club anymore!

This tilapia has a strong, off taste to me. It's not fishy nor spoiled, but it's not tasty. I've noticed this taste in other tilapia, but I had read that Member's Mark tilapia didnt have it. It does. My husband said he doesn't taste it, so I'll cook it for him. The filets are good size and fairly uniform. If you like it, the price is good.

I normally get tilapia once or twice a month. The size of the fish is pretty good. The only issue I have is that lately 2 or 3 fish out of the pack are rotten. I defrost as directed open the pack and there’s the rancid smell of rotting fish. The smell is strong like ammonia. I stopped getting the fish last month because of that. I’ve already been to the store and returned the fish and they were very nice about it and understanding.

I enjoy the flavor this fish brings to my soups and salads. Individual packaging keeps the remaining fish fresh for a later date. The fish are unseasoned so I can add the flavor of MY choice to my foods without having to fight a flavor in mass production.

If you want thin smaller pieces of Tilapia this will be good but if you are as I was thinking it's thicker pieces of filets, then you won't be happy. I will use what I have because it's a matter of thinking it was one thing and getting another not the quality or taste, that is fine. The package shows what I usually find to be larger and thicker pieces and these are thin and small.

I love this fish. The fish are wrapped individually.

Great tasting fish. We eat it several times a week. Great cooked in butter and lemon juice.

Good for healthy eating regimen

Tilapia was very good, fresh and mild.

One in the bread box the other in the freezer! That’s a win, win!